News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by TeMPOraL on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:52PM (#21887548)
Huh, you're right about my "subjective urbanist bias", I didn't even notice it in my thinking. Thanks!

WRT. doctors vs. drug/diagnostic equipment manufacturers, a good point, but here I specifically picked my example - public health and safety vs. entertainment - to maximize the contrast.

> Perhaps the concept of "social value" is only useful in the context of societies small enough so that all participants can agree on values?

I think there might be a correlation between community size and the ease of agreeing on what is social value, but I wouldn't discount it for larger societies or even humanity as a whole. Humans do have a lot in common, and I feel you can get far in ranking jobs by social value by going along the gradient of reduction of suffering. And I say "jobs", not "professions", because IMO, professions are almost orthogonal to social value. For example, in terms of the social value, I'd rank a programmer working on diagnostic equipment > programmer working on a videogame > programmer working on advertising tech. The skillset and productivity may be similar or even the same, but these jobs occupy three very different point on the "making the world a better place" scale.

There are no comments on this comment yet.