Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I...
by nugget on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:59PM
(#21887180)
Great childcare and elder care is very expensive and the people who do these jobs well are, in my experience, quite well compensated relative to other jobs available to them.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I...
by noonespecial on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:05PM
(#21887231)
>Great childcare and elder care is very expensive
It's hard even to find a way to buy "Great childcare and elder care". Mostly you end up paying as much as such a thing should cost but the money just goes to people who "administer" minimum wage workers delivering care that is mediocre at best.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I...
by ip26 on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:17PM
(#21887307)
I ran through the numbers when my kid started in childcare. It turned out there wasn't really a grand bureaucratic conspiracy. Instead, mainly labor is just really expensive.
When your kids are still infants, at childcare centers, the caretaker:child ratio can get as high as 1:2. Those caretakers gross nearly $30k/year plus benefits & other employer costs such as FICA & Medicare.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I...
by elil17 on Thursday December 26, 2019 @06:09PM
(#21887655)
$30k/year is not a lot of money - definitely not enough to raise your own kids on
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I...
by ip26 on Thursday December 26, 2019 @09:14PM
(#21888579)
No, but it does mean that as a parent, if (in this canned example) you are paying $18k/year- while the number initially sounds crazy- nearly all of it is going directly to caretaker compensation, not bloat & largess.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I...
by pmiller2 on Friday December 27, 2019 @01:42PM
(#21893281)
Maybe not, but it's a lot of money for most families to pay someone else to take care of their kids.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I...
by sdfin on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:12PM
(#21887280)
Aren't there childcare and elder care agencies that aim at families of different socioeconomic levels? I guess that the rich hire expensive nannies at expensive agencies.
What you comment sounds unlikely to me.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I...
by nugget on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:13PM
(#21887281)
I agree there’s a sourcing/matching problem that leads the administrators in these markets to capture a disproportionately large share of any value premiums paid.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I...
by michaelt on Friday December 27, 2019 @02:15PM
(#21893619)
I agree childcare you pay for is often expensive - I was thinking more of the unpaid work done by stay-at-home parents and families caring for their own elders - who earn no direct salary for their efforts. But nobody would say they ought to stop.