News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by roenxi on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:13PM (#21886836)
It remains very frustrating watching people organise against inequality as the evil of this era. Inequality isn't worth railing against and the focus of all this attention should be on living standards.

If everyone doubles their living standards over 10 years, absolute inequality rises (there is always going to be someone with no wealth/income because they want to live that way, so the absolute gap in wealth increases as the wealthiest member of society gets wealthier).

If the amount of wealth is doubled due to some center of extreme productivity (eg, a Silicon Valley) then that center is going to get preferential access to new wealth. Relative inequality rises.

In both of these scenarios, wealth inequality and living standards can raise in tandem. These are perfectly fine outcomes. Inequality is only interesting as a symptom of deeper issues affecting living standards. Should workers be rewarded according to their productivity? That would be nice, but then we would need to be very careful how we decided who got what job. There are jobs that are rare, highly productive and easy to do where the people holding them would be unfairly rewarded. That would be similar to what we have now. Focusing on median & minimum living standards will get much better results. If those are rising, inequality is not an issue.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by smallnamespace on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:28PM (#21886952)
I'm going to speak directly to your point, which is the claim that only absolute wealth matters, but relative wealth does not.

Relative wealth buys you status, position, and power in society. That status protects you when things go wrong, when the system fails to measure or optimize for the things that you care about, or when the music suddenly stops and you find that you're the one left without a chair.

People deeply care about not being on the bottom of the pecking order, because if you look at history, when anything goes wrong, it's always those at the bottom who get hit the hardest - whether it's famine, war, economic recession, or any of the myriad of instabilities and ills that visit our societies from time to time.

Your contention that we should only care about minimum living standards requires a large amount of faith, not just in the system as it stands today, but that the system won't slowly erode those minimums over time because the poor lack the political and social power to keep their minimums. Without the power to protect your own interests, you're at the literal mercy of those who are better off than you to throw you a bone when you're most vulnerable.

And the best guarantor of social and political power is to be necessary - to be a critical component of the means of production. Automation, outsourcing, and foreign competition have all been chipping away at the competitive position of the median American worker.

A look at the path of inflation-adjusted minimum wage, the evisceration of unions, the opioid crisis, the recent Great Recession, the fact that standard housing, schooling, and medical care is becoming increasingly out of reach of the average wage-earners would suggest that in fact, life is not getting better for those at the bottom, despite the very large increase in absolute wealth since the 1970s.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by iguy on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:10PM (#21887264)
> Relative wealth buys you status, position > pecking order

Some of this can't really be fixed: the top 10% of status only has room for 10% of the people, by definition. The pecking order, by definition, orders people.

> and power in society.

This seems like a better focus. How much extra power you gain by being on top varies a great deal between different societies (including earlier and later versions of any one country). This seems like the relevant variable.

I'm not sure that this inequality of power is very well measured by monetary inequality. There is some correlation, because power can usually be turned into material comfort. But I'm not sure how much higher taxes or whatever remedy like that is proposed for moving money around, will move power around.

> the best guarantor of social and political power is to be necessary

I hear what you're saying, roughly about changes in the last 50 years in western countries. But it is also easy to think of large classes of absolutely necessary workers who had very little power, in many places and times. So I'm not sure that that's enough.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by ip26 on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:45PM (#21887510)
As we've moved towards greater wealth inequality, it is also argued that we've moved towards wealth having greater access to power. (Citizens United, one dollar one vote, decline of unions, etc) You can go after wealth inequality, or you can go after the power-wealth connection. I'm not sure which is easier.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by iguy on Thursday December 26, 2019 @07:11PM (#21887989)
I'm not sure these connections are as clear as you seem to take them to be. I guess I should cite PG instead of re-typing... maybe we're still unwinding the world of WWII, which produces lots of correlated changes [1]. Maybe inequality is more about technology than tax laws [2].

[1] http://paulgraham.com/re.html [2] http://paulgraham.com/ineq.html

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by nugget on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:29PM (#21887391)
As I watch pop culture media I can’t help but think that the desire for relative wealth/status is driven primarily by the desire to attract sexual and romantic partners. I don’t think people in their 20s and 30s are as worried about war and famine as they are about being undesirable, unpopular, rejected, and lonely. At least not in the US. I suppose sex tech and AR/VR tech could advance to the point where some of these fears are obliviated and humans begin to deprogram the desire for status within a social hierarchy. That would be quite a radical evolution.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by zozbot234 on Friday December 27, 2019 @10:34AM (#21891860)
> Relative wealth buys you status, position, and power in society.

Social cohesion (including political involvement, etc.) buys these things far more effectively than money or any market mechanism. "Relative wealth" is a highly imperfect substitute for high social capital.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by roenxi on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:52PM (#21887134)
> Your contention that we should only care about minimum living standards requires a large amount of faith, not just in the system as it stands today, but that the system won't slowly erode those minimums over time because the poor lack the political and social power to keep their minimums. Without the power to protect your own interests, you're at the literal mercy of those who are better off than you to throw you a bone when you're most vulnerable.

Yeah, exactly. The focus should be on stuff like that rather than on wealth/income inequality; I can see we are on the same wavelength here. The natural solution to what you are talking about is to find ways to increase the standards of people who are not well off.

The natural solution to inequality is to disenfranchise the wealthy, which doesn't put food on the table (literally, in the extreme China/Russia/Zimbabwe style cases). It works really badly & everyone important tries to migrate somewhere capitalist when it is tried, which is a contributing factor to why it generally isn't the done thing.

If the focus is on inequality, then realising that a policy is not working will take a long time. If the focus is on living standards, feedback will be quick.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by helen___keller on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:15PM (#21887300)
> The natural solution to inequality is to disenfranchise the wealthy, which doesn't put food on the table

To use an example from the leftmost mainstream politicians in the United States, a current proposal is to enact a wealth tax on fortunes over $X million to fund a larger social safety net.

You can argue that ideologically the focus should be on standards of living, not on inequality, but realistically a wealth tax fulfills both.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by neilwilson on Friday December 27, 2019 @01:22AM (#21889591)
Why not simply accommodate the savings rather than constantly trying to confiscate them? A dynamic monetary system can do that.

I don't understand this obsession on the left with behaving like Robin Hood. Wealth taxes will not alter the power position of the rich. All it does is get up the nose of the rich and require us to pay those people who want to play Robin Hood.

QE labour hours however, and the power of the wealthy to deny others an income by not spending their haul is removed. They can count their coin and the poor still get to work and eat.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by helen___keller on Friday December 27, 2019 @11:07AM (#21892060)
I'm not sure I understand what your proposal is but the answer to your question of "why wealth tax", the answer is pretty much because it's simple to convey and rally behind.

Deficit spending (or straight up "money printing") could provide benefits to those who need it without taxation, but decades of political obsession over "how are we gonna pay for it" means that people feel better if a policy of "buy X" is followed by "while taking money from Y to pay for it"

For Republicans, the Y is some nefarious unnamed government bloat or waste, but never military. Most recently it's food stamps, and as I understand it there's a lot of hungry gazes staring at social security and medicaid.

For Democrats, the Y is some nefarious wealthy entity, either Big Corporations or The Rich. So, ambitious far left proposals involve taxing wealth, adding very high marginal tax rates at the top, and taxing corporations and investment vehicles. This is often silly for obvious reasons. For example, Bernie suggests taxing stock transactions, bond trades, and derivatives transactions, by a (low) percentage, which sounds insane personally. But that stocks and derivatives sounds like Evil Wall Street Bullshit to some voters so they eat it up.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by neilwilson on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @05:16AM (#21927458)
By definition if you spend more, you tax more. Every amount of govt spending is matched by an increase in taxation to the penny for any positive tax rate. The only thing that stops that is increases in private saving along the route.

Why do you want to stop increased saving?

The 'wealth tax' doesn't work because it doesn't stop the 'wealthy' from bidding on the thing government is trying to buy. So you are just going to cause inflation.

Why not try explaining to people how the system actually works?

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by huntertwo on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:23PM (#21886910)
But we can ignore the need to increase productivity enough (which is hard) in order to achieve better standards for all if we just take from those at the tippy top who hoard wealth that could be used to help those in need. We have enough resources/wealth and productivity now to help the rest but we don’t. The issue is that despite the continuous increase in wealth and productivity, the distribution is inequal enough to make sure that the worst never reach the conditions that they deserve as human beings. We can solve the problem with resources that exist now and the unequal distribution is getting worse, we shouldn’t keep kicking the can down the road and not focusing on inequality.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by CJefferson on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:25PM (#21886924)
Over the past 20 years, the amount of wealth has increased substansally, and almost none of the gain has gone to those at the bottom of society. Inequality is growing every year.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by underpand on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:42PM (#21887054)
Don't the bottom of society all have access to the advancements in technology now e.g. 4g, high speed internet, smart phones, mobile apps, video games

Access to technology is a form of wealth.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by joe_the_user on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:32PM (#21887411)
Your discussion along with the your GP treat "wealth" as an undifferentiated substance, where a greater total amount inherently involves a better life.

The problem with this is that human beings are limited biological creatures with a variety of wants and needs each of which is not interchangeable with the other. Having a powerful smart phone with access to the Internet no doubt give a person greater variety of stimulous, the potential for entertainment, connection with those in near and distant land and whatever else. It satisfies what we might call the desire for entertainment, creativity or whatever. But it can't be directly substituted for food, clothing, shelter or a temperature controlled environment. So the situation of a homeless person with a smart phone freezing at night is better than a middle class person in the 1950s - even if we count the homeless person as having $1 million dollars in wealth measured by 1950s standard - since hey, that smart phone is lots of "wealth".

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by eli_gottlieb on Thursday December 26, 2019 @11:39PM (#21889227)
The top 1% has taken most of the growth. The top 10% have received some table-scraps. The bottom 90% have lost income.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by refurb on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:39PM (#21887032)
That’s clearly not true, at least in the US. Total compensation has outpaced inflation significantly.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by CJefferson on Friday December 27, 2019 @04:28AM (#21890189)
Wages after inflation haven't budged in 44 years: https://www.forbes.com/sites/joshbersin/2018/10/31/why-arent...

I know the UK situation much better than the US situation.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by chc on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:42PM (#21887480)
This seems like a non sequitur. Total compensation vs. inflation is not a measure of inequality.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by xyzzyz on Thursday December 26, 2019 @09:45PM (#21888714)
Yes, but the grandparent claimed that

> and almost none of the gain has gone to those at the bottom of society

which is not true, since real compensation at the bottom of society has also gone up.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by chc on Friday December 27, 2019 @02:45PM (#21893893)
By all the numbers I've seen, that's not really the case. For one example, according to the Congressional Research Service[1], inflation-adjusted wages for the bottom 10% of earners have been stagnant since the start of the 1980s, and inflation-adjusted wages for the bottom 50% have been nearly stagnant, with small gains that consist almost entirely of women's income getting closer to parity with men's.

[1]: https://crsreports.congress.gov/search/#/?termsToSearch=r450...

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by sagarm on Thursday December 26, 2019 @07:32PM (#21888090)
Economic power is leveraged into political power. This power is used to maintain the status quo in favor of the currently economically powerful through regulatory capture, patronage, and increasingly outright corruption.

We cannot remain an egalitarian democracy if economic power continues to concentrate as it has, regardless of median living standards.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by TulliusCicero on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:20PM (#21887326)
There's only so much power in society, and when inequality goes up, the power of the affluent rises, while the power of the poor and working class wanes.

This isn't an issue that can be fixed by a rising tide lifting all boats.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by jyounker on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:23PM (#21887350)
Wealth translates to political influence. If most of the wealth in a society belongs to a few people, those people have outsized influence on the those in power. Conversely, the more distributed wealth is within the society, the more representative the government will be.

In a deep sense wealth distribution is about what form of government you want to have. If you want an oligopoly, then you let the majority if the wealth go to a few people. If you want a government that looks after most of the citizens, then you want a more equitable distribution of wealth.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by tchaffee on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:36PM (#21887016)
There is plenty of evidence showing that huge gaps in equality are highly correlated with increased unhappiness at both ends of the spectrum, along with other negatives like increased crime. Humans are social animals, so a part of living standards will always be around power structures and fairness. You can't just give people at the bottom nice things to erase that.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by dmwallin on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:45PM (#21887083)
From a purely macro-economic capitalistic viewpoint, there's a lot of evidence that a high level of inequality actually depresses economic growth. This means a very strong argument can be made that addressing inequality is likely to increase both relative AND absolute living standards in the long run.
Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by chowells on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:51PM (#21887119)
The reason people care about inequality is that under capitalism, it's the measure that best tracks with quality of life in the lowest standards of living.

Why is capitalism relevant? Because the driving economic force under capitalism is that the rich (capital owners) want to get richer (earn returns on their capital investments).

Why doesn't a rising tide lift all boats, in practice? Because that doesn't maximize return on capital. The people who financed development and operation of a hospital get the best returns on their investments by pricing things out of reach of those with the least. You don't maximize area of a rectangle under an income distribution curve by making the lowest point of the curve the top of the rectangle.

Perhaps the best way to think of it is "a rising tide lifts all boats, but some of them aren't lifted by as much as the water level has risen." Not quite as snappy, is it? It does get the point across, though. Inequality functions as a measure of how many boats aren't keeping up with the rising water level.

That's why so many people care about it. It's the same thing as your goal, but bundled up as an aggregate and easy to track, instead of involving hundreds of subjective measures. No measure is perfect, of course, but it's a lot harder to game than something like the CPI is.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by itiri83njd on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:33PM (#21886996)
Inequality in living standards is exactly what they’re talking about when they talk about inequality.

Perhaps you should familiarize yourself with the nuanced discourse of groups tackling these problems directly at the political level, instead of taking textbook definitions of words and none of the context of the broader social movements behind the effort.

“Wealth” is a measure of relative living standards. You’re talking about the same damn thing these groups do but somehow seem annoyed at your own lack of experience with the political conversation.

DRY can apply to more than code. No reason to reinvent definitions and quantify problems when people have already spent a lifetime discussing these things.

Get off HN and engage directly maybe, rather than getting circle and repetitive.

Humanity built bridges and roads and trade before it had any answers like we do about physics and math. We do not need or rely on the uptight definitions in academia. Language is mushed up as needed.

STEM headed nerds would be wise to forget their academia a bit and their propensity for falling into functional fixedness when it comes to language

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by fnovd on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:47PM (#21887094)
>"Wealth" is a measure of relative living standards.

No, it is not. This is like saying wealth is a measure of how fancy your car is. Correlated, sure, but calling it a measure is inaccurate at best and at worst an attempt to eschew nuance in favor of ideological conformity.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by itiri83njd on Thursday December 26, 2019 @05:43PM (#21887489)
You emotionally qualify it isn’t and that’s it.

If you have something quantifiable to peddle here that never brushes up against human ideology, go for it.

Otherwise your reply is no different than mine.

See politically I can label it with as much nuance as I want. So can anyone. There is no “one way” to view things. There’s very meticulous and nuanced ways, but I don’t have to adopt them as part of my political tool belt.

Any ideas and nuance we hold onto in our head outside of what physics and chemistry say the structure of matter looks like at various speeds relative to light, is subjective human ideology.

Whichever ideology holds official power “wins.” Largely by saying some other ideology is deficient we’re picking this one instead.

So... quantify it with something other than a human ideology then?

Pure math economics models are invalid. Human biology doesn’t need to conform to the behaviors within. It’s academic economists trying to find a causative conclusion from physics to wealth accumulation to defend political ideology.

Re:Valuing Productivity, Not Profession, Could Reduce U.S. I... by snidane on Thursday December 26, 2019 @04:30PM (#21886963)
These statements about 'absolute living standards' are utter crap because they absolutely ignore the law of rent. Simply stated the more people in a given city make the higher the rents, fees and cost of living in general. The more the middle class makes the more is taken away from them. Middle class then keeps only paying fees left and right and witnessing ever increasing poverty around them.

The resulting state of prospering areas filled with poverty has been called the paradox of progress and poverty because the more prosperous area you have the more homelessness and disgusting living conditions you find. Whether it is San Francisco with their smelly homeless neighborhoods, Hong Kong with 4sqft apartments or London during industrial revolution as described by Dickens in Oliver Twist.

Sadly the 'absolute living standard' fairy tale is perpetuated by people on the economical right which makes anyone on the left dismiss anything further they say. (I'm on the right myself, but this crap infuriates me).

The relevant items to study in order to understand this effect 1. Law of Rent by David Ricardo 2. Henry George theorem