Re:Colleges are turning students’ phones into surveillance m...
by DreamScatter on Thursday December 26, 2019 @11:00PM
(#21889057)
I don't expect a university advisor to have surveillance data on me, I expect them to be busy with their own work, and that I can come to them for assistance when I need. It's up to the student to communicate the situation.. this should be a human interaction and not automated.
As for recognizing the fact that students might expect or deserve privacy, and the affront to dignity, etc., I was quite clear that we are as transparent an upfront as we can be about this, and students have the ability to tell us "no". Beyond that, the concept of "affront to dignity" on the matter is a personal opinion on the topic, not an axiomatic ethical marker. Similarly "expectation of privacy" is not an unmovable value. My school, in part because of a years-long careful deliberation on the topic, was behind the times in this area. As a result, I cannot tell you how many times students speak to advisors and are actually frustrated that the advisor does not know some of these things about the student, that the advisor has to ask if the student has been attending classes, what their midterm grade is, etc. The students expect us to have all of this data at our fingertips because they expect a seamless, friction-less level of service.
Maybe you'd say "that's just because they're used to so many organizations collecting data," and sure, you'd be right (my apologies if the the words I put in your mouth aren't one's you'd say or agree with) But here's the thing: If it's what they expect, what they want, and done responsibly, what is the problem? To contradict the students' attitudes puts you in a position of telling other people that what they want is wrong, and that they should want other things that you think are best for them. Again, my apologies if that doesn't correspond with your own ideas. It is, however, not an uncommon stance, so I think the point still stands.