News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Colleges are turning students’ phones into surveillance m... by ineedasername on Wednesday December 25, 2019 @08:42PM (#21881561)
You're absolutely right, data could be used for these other things that, while potentially beneficial to society and individuals, carry further potential for misuse as well.

To address misuse in general: That is always a problem, with any technology, tool, data... anything. It's important that we don't discard useful tools due to potential misuse though. Instead, it's of the utmost importance that, at the outset, issues of misuse be enumerated, discussed, mitigation strategies thought out, how to accurately talk about data gathered, the insights obtained, what they can and cannot be used for from a statistical analysis (correlation != causation etc. type of thing) and so on. Let me talk a little about what we did at my institution along these lines. It wasn't perfect, we could have done better, but in the outlines I think it formed a pretty good starting place for a template of how society should engage in conversations about issues that arise from the current revolution in our ability to gather data on individuals:

In 2014 we started using an LMS system that made data collection on easy. I was given sole access to that data to begin exploring and cataloging the available data being collected, it's possible uses, potential points of concern. I had sole access, but those things I was looking for were done in intense conversation with administrative and faculty colleagues, including the university executive board and the faculty union and faculty senate along with conversations with students. During this process, no else had the level of unfettered access that I did (I am a data analyst) not even the system administrators. (Technically they could have granted themselves access though, but if they didn't go through the proper channels, such a thing is a firing offense.)

This went on for about three years, all the while I was able to accumulate data and evaluate it against actual student performance and validate its utility and continue to report back on my findings to further the discussions going on. When that stage of actually using the data to drive conversations ended, I took a step back and simply spoke at gatherings every once in a while to go over what I'd done, findings, etc. After that, for the next two years, it was in the hands of the administration working up policies in conversation with faculty surrounding expectations for responsible use of this information. To say there were disagreements would be an understatement. But over time tentative points of compromise were reached, and for the past 2 years were have begun carefully rolling out initiatives that utilize all of this. We are cautious. We are open. We continue to have conversations with valid concerns on all sides that we seek good compromises for.

Again, the above wasn't perfect, but it's a good outline of how responsible use of data should be approached.

Re:Colleges are turning students’ phones into surveillance m... by DreamScatter on Thursday December 26, 2019 @10:48PM (#21889013)
Is it open source / free software?

These things should not be allowed to be proprietary software.. if I attend a public institution that surveils me, I want the surveilance software to be fully open source and I want to be able to know all the data points you would have on me.

Then, I would like to decide for myself whether I want to participate or not.