News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reviewing Bad Schematics as EE Interview Tactic by PascLeRasc on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @01:25AM (#21870296)
Ok, to be fair, they did say "when we turned it on, part of it blew up" when I asked for more details, and it was just a 2-page schematic with 6-7 subsections. I think it was pretty fair, I'm just frustrated that it felt like I couldn't solve it by thinking slowly and methodically.

It was a really cool company and I'd have loved to work there. It's the kind of place where I want to be a good fit.

Re:Reviewing Bad Schematics as EE Interview Tactic by mng2 on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @04:41PM (#21875087)
Did they tell you exactly where it blew up? Then it might be fair, 2 pages is not that big. Though you'd still be at quite a disadvantage compared to someone who spent a lot of time designing the thing.

I gotta say though, if they themselves designed this board that promptly blew up, perhaps they should recalibrate their expectations for EEs.

Re:Reviewing Bad Schematics as EE Interview Tactic by makomk on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @06:25AM (#21871302)
I do wonder if this is just a scenario where there's no way to win. The person writing this blog post has exactly the same interview prompt - something went pop when the board was powered up - but they expect candidates to spot subtle things like missing decoupling capacitors that almost certainly aren't the cause of the problem.
Re:Reviewing Bad Schematics as EE Interview Tactic by cushychicken on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @09:04AM (#21872102)
Just about every person I've used this prompt on has found the prompted error, and then gone on to find a few more. However, I don't really care about the number of errors you find nearly so much as I do seeing and hearing you reason your way through a new problem.

I don't expect you to find all the issues. (But if you do, then congratulations! I'm gonna try to hire you.) I do expect you to talk to me about your thought process when confronted with a novel issue.

That's what good electrical engineers do. They don't know all the answers - they reason their way through unexpected challenges.