News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Stanford Professor Says Juul Stole Her Anti-Vaping Powe... by dehrmann on Monday December 23, 2019 @10:56PM (#21869721)
The title (from BuzzFeedNews) leaves out that the slides were plagiarized by Juul, then Juul paid schools to teach them, all while name-dropping The Farm.

I'm trying to tease apart how much of the plagiarism is to be expected when you're an academic, whether Juul was being more manipulative or lazy, and is paying schools to teach this a token gesture, an insult, or inception marketing.

Re:A Stanford Professor Says Juul Stole Her Anti-Vaping Powe... by jdsully on Monday December 23, 2019 @11:42PM (#21869927)
> how much of the plagiarism is to be expected when you're an academic

Last I checked academics have the same rights under copyright as the rest of us.

Re:A Stanford Professor Says Juul Stole Her Anti-Vaping Powe... by dehrmann on Monday December 23, 2019 @11:52PM (#21869953)
IANAL, but it's complicated because this was(?) produced as part of her employment by Stanford, so arguably Juul took Stanford's work. Stanford is private, it can do what it wants, but what about public universities? Should the public own the IP they fund? IP created by public employees in the US are often released into the public domain. What if a professor from a private school got a government grant? I'm not sure how settled any of this is legally.
Re:A Stanford Professor Says Juul Stole Her Anti-Vaping Powe... by geofft on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @12:29AM (#21870094)
Not just "released" - works created by federal officers and employees cannot be copyrighted in the first place. But public universities are run by states/territories/etc., not by the federal government, and there's no such restriction on state governments. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_status_of_works_by_s...

Another interesting case: works done by government contractors are eligible for copyright protection, and the copyright can be transferred to the government, which is, I think, how parts of OpenStack can be copyrighted by NASA. By that argument, professors (or anyone else) with government grants should definitely be able to copyright their work and keep copyright.

There's certainly an increasingly-popular argument that publicly-funded research work should be publicly accessible / open access, but there's no law or even norm about it yet.

Re:A Stanford Professor Says Juul Stole Her Anti-Vaping Powe... by dehrmann on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @12:58AM (#21870174)
> There's certainly an increasingly-popular argument that publicly-funded research work should be publicly accessible

JSTOR. Because you should pay for it twice.

Re:A Stanford Professor Says Juul Stole Her Anti-Vaping Powe... by antpol on Tuesday December 24, 2019 @08:53AM (#21872034)
As far as I know University of California system makes a good revenue on the IP they created
Re:A Stanford Professor Says Juul Stole Her Anti-Vaping Powe... by caseyf7 on Monday December 23, 2019 @11:05PM (#21869764)
Inception marketing....I hope that doesn’t catch on, but it sounds like 2021’s growth hacking.
Re:A Stanford Professor Says Juul Stole Her Anti-Vaping Powe... by musicale on Monday December 23, 2019 @11:13PM (#21869808)
Marketing and market research.