I've been playing the game in both the "Cartoon" and "3D" visual style for years and it's been a very pleasant and eye-pleasing experience for me. Please open your world a bit for me. Maybe share some of your design work for inspiration. Thanks in advance for your feedback.
In general I like styles that either:
- just go all the way in the stylized direction, like Bad North [1], The Witness [2] or even Clash of Clans [3] (to be honest I also dislike CoC-style popular with mobile games nowadays, but at least it's consistent/harmonious in its candy-plasticky look)
- OR they actually try to do the realistic-style part, like the classic Age of Empires, or toony-ish-ralisticky like more modern Northgard [4]
- OR they fully embrace the blocky style like Minecraft, or the 8-bit/pixelated style of clearly retro-style games
"In between" styles just look... annoying, giving a "sand in your eye" mental sensation of the early 90s games that were too shallow and childish. It lacks some "higher harmony" thing that I can't describe any better. I get this "allergic" reaction also when I see this style in clothing or architecture or whatever.
Anyway, keep up the work if you and others enjoy it, don't be discouraged by people that just prefer smth else!
I'm just a bit sad bc I probably would've liked the game mechanics, but the style totally turns me off.
[1] https://store.steampowered.com/app/688420/Bad_North_Jotunn_E...
[2] https://store.steampowered.com/app/210970/The_Witness/
[3] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.supercell....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J7LK0s8LgmQ
Maybe this style appeals more to you?
That said, with the same level of detail I'm brought to mind of the original Xbox Fable game which in my humble opinion had really excellent art direction for its day -- a mixture of cartoon-y, arty, and moody but only only at times, not constantly gloomy like modern games. Consistent lighting and selective contrast in detail.
Actually, even the 360 remake was a step backwards! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gib34dN0zXI
...I don't mean the quality, it's understandable resources are constrained. I mean the actual artistic decisions... it burns your visual cortex with all those colors and textures fighting each other. What's the theme, "kindergardeners on acid meeting Elvis"?! or "South Park but in Fortnite drawn while drunk"?