Re:France to Raise Pollution Tax on SUVs and Trucks to €22k
by Karto on Monday December 23, 2019 @04:47AM
(#21862548)
Pity. I live in a remote part of France, shaped by hills, forests, and very devoid of public services. Most people don't have too much money, yet every third car you see is an SUV or 4WD, because they actually are quite useful in daily life. My neighbour drives a tiny but nimble Suzuki Vitara with which he does just everything, much of which no regular city car could do. Was he to buy that same car in two years, it'd cost almost twice as much because of those taxes. (damn even the baker drives his deliveries with a Vitara).
I see all the excesses around the SUVs, I agree there's a nuisance to be dealt with. But again the government rules with a large and blind PR hammer, and we'll quietly sit under the blow once more.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:France to Raise Pollution Tax on SUVs and Trucks to €22k
by pjc50 on Monday December 23, 2019 @04:54AM
(#21862574)
Suzuki Vitara is an 8"CV" car: https://www.neowebcar.com/puissance-fiscale/suzuki/vitara/1-... which would incur €6250 tax.
(It's amazing how well Bloomberg's propaganda has worked here, hasn't it?)
Re:France to Raise Pollution Tax on SUVs and Trucks to €22k
by Karto on Monday December 23, 2019 @05:29AM
(#21862725)
6000 Euro tax for a 15000 euro car. I'd call it significant enough and ridiculous enough to be more than mere propaganda. But you're right, the figures I had in the mind were for the Jimny, not the Vitara. Over 10000 tax for a car that's less than 20000 euro.
Re:France to Raise Pollution Tax on SUVs and Trucks to €22k
by frede on Monday December 23, 2019 @04:59AM
(#21862596)
Your neighbor will be fine. The taxes start at 160 g CO2/km. The Vitara has between 121 and 172 g/km.
Re:France to Raise Pollution Tax on SUVs and Trucks to €22k
by adrianN on Monday December 23, 2019 @05:46AM
(#21862800)
Meanwhile people in urban areas pay a lot more for rent so that they don't need large cars. Seems fair to me.
Re:France to Raise Pollution Tax on SUVs and Trucks to €22k
by Karto on Monday December 23, 2019 @06:46AM
(#21863040)
Reduce a complex equation to only two variables ? But that's no the point : expecting fairness isn't practical anyway. :) I'd bet the practical response will be people stretching their car's lifespans way beyond reasonable, pushing them to new extremes of decrepitude and unsafety. There's also no police anyway to keep that in check.