You could charge, but then you might fail in the market due to competitors not charging. You can attempt to build a market for your time, by giving away the software.
Successful software sales are a function of your support costs (assuming you've jumped the first hurdle which is writing a product people want to buy).
x% of your customers will take up y hours of your time. The software (and support materials) must be designed so that x and y are reducing in size as time goes by.
Free software with paid support is more like consultancy. To scale means more staff.
Paying for support is also more complicated - there must necessarily be a two-way conversation about work done, hours taken, etc. Collecting money for software is a one-way conversaton - here's the price, take it or leave it.
If you are releasing free software then it doesn't matter since your not offering support any way, so it's not bad.
Closed source development does not scale - it is limited to the available work hours and imagination of the owners.
I had a lot of fun doing support & sales work with clients as sales engineer for an open source software company. Access to free software is, obviously, great for me as a user.
On the other hand, it seems harder for very small companies to make a living on support (the kind you can really charge for, SLAs with big corps etc) than to sell an iPhone app, for example.
Also, if you're making your money on support, there's a possibility you might be less motivated to make your product very easy to use (not that paid software is always great in that respect, of course).