Re:Costly but worthless gifts facilitate courtship
by srean on Sunday February 06, 2011 @01:16AM
(#2185127)
Could you elaborate ? Did you have any particular parameter in mind.
To me the model seemed strikingly simple with just 6 parameters. All assumptions seemed very mild, benign and sensible. Furthermore they list out the behavior and the nature of the equilibrium at different settings of those parameters.
There could be different points of criticism of the work, but over-dependence or sensitivity to finely tuned parameters does not seem to be very strong to me in this particular case.
Re:Costly but worthless gifts facilitate courtship
by joe_the_user on Sunday February 06, 2011 @02:42AM
(#2185207)
I phrased my initial comment poorly.
I didn't mean any specific parameters within the model they are using.
I meant the quantities and framework which are looked to generate the model itself. For example, whether there is one quality "attractiveness" in a woman or say, two, "attractiveness" plus "pleasantness", etc.
And unless you have really powerful evidence that your particular parameters are preferable, all you have accomplished is do a really go job of filling in a hypothetical argument. That doesn't prove you're wrong. It's just a long way from showing your right.