I've noticed on Google searches for OKCupid and Plenty of Fish that among the suggested completions are "OKCupid scam" and "Plenty of Fish scam". Among the results on those pages are plentyoffishscam.com and okcupidscam.net. Those are blogs, both slamming the dating sites they are named after, and both recommending cougarlife.com, ashleymadison.com, and arrengementseekers.com.
It's pretty apparent that these blogs are written by the same person. (Oh, I just remembered, there is also eharmonyscam.com, also clearly by the same people and recommending the same three sites).
There are also many other blogs that quote these blogs, and it seems likely that many of these are fake, too. I think I've seen them quoted on legitimate-appearing forums, too, so there is a real possibility the cougarlife.com people are spamming forums.
The one that we're sure has been used is simply scrape profiles from somewhere else. Someone just did that, scraping from Facebook, and it made quite a stir. At first you'd think that could not even have a remote chance of working, as the scraped people would certainly notice when you started matching them for dates!
If you were a bit smarter, though (and unethical people can be smart), you'd just use those scraped profiles to make your site look busy. You'd never match anyone to them. You'd only make matches among people who actually come to the site and register.