If you disable checking all together, then an attacker doesn't need to compromise a private key. Any impersonation attack will just work.
If you require the user to accept a specific cert (and store that information) then you can just as well let the user accept an expired cert.
The current situation just creates a lot of hassle for people without any security benefit.
Key rotation is completely separate from the lifetime of a cert. You can renew certs while keeping keys constant forever. In practice, if your key gets compromised and you have to wait for the cert to expire, then you have a very big problem. Even with letsencrypt it is likely more than a month before the cert expires.
In my experience, many "security" people see this as the purpose of their job.