Re:The Liar's Walk: Detecting Deception with Gait and Gesture
by justanotherjoe on Friday December 20, 2019 @12:36AM
(#21841946)
You're not kidding.
"In this procedure, the deceptive walk is induced by the
experimenter during the briefing, the type of object, and the
appearance of the confederate"
This is not deceptive walking, this is honest walking. They are honestly trying to broadcast the signal that they were told to broadcast.
So yeah! No surprise! They told the participant to act sketchy, and they did! What did the participant do? They put their hands in their pocket and looked around a bunch more than normally. Why? Because they were basically told to! That's not "deceptive walking".
Where is the control for picking up the papers off the floor, or the money off the table? How do we know it's not just that people will walk differently when they are about to crouch down? Maybe that would be an interesting paper by itself, but instead the authors think that this type of research is capable of identifying "deception" with 93% accuracy? Absurd!
There is so much wrong with the experiment, that you could write a rebuttal of almost every decision they made.