News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Depression and suicide linked to air pollution in new glo... by corin_ on Thursday December 19, 2019 @07:38AM (#21834333)
If the result to the user (getting a machine that leaves them with clean air except 1 type of polutant at exactly the level that polutant would be without the machine), is it really different ethically based on whether the machine leaves that polutant or removes then replaces it?

Seems kind of like saying (although this example is certainly less ethical to those of us who oppose murder and death penalties) that there's a difference ethically between killing someone by putting poison into their body vs. killing them by preventing food/water to go into their body.

But as to achieving it, sure I wasn't proposing it as necessarily a good or feasible option - other the little bit of research I did when choosing which air purifier for my bedroom I don't know much about the technology.

I was more just thinking about the ethical question if it were possible, since I can appreciate the argument against it but like I said, I personally would be completely happy for a research team to offer me the hypothetical machine.

Re:Depression and suicide linked to air pollution in new glo... by close04 on Thursday December 19, 2019 @08:43AM (#21834800)
This is probably more of a philosophical point. But if you removed all pollutants then by putting one back in you're actually poisoning your subject.

I guess it's the difference between a surgeon operating and taking out 90% of a tumor, and a surgeon taking out the whole tumor then putting a bit back in. But again, I am not an ethics expert, this is just me bouncing ideas.