News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Giving every IPv6 address a name by jrockway on Monday December 16, 2019 @08:25PM (#21809569)
ACME is entirely based on DNS. The HTTP and ALPN challenges look up which IP address to speak to via DNS. The DNS challenges look for a TXT record in DNS. (Letsencrypt tries pretty hard to ensure that the DNS is legitimately being served by looking up the IP address from multiple networks, so you can't disrupt one of their networks to issue fake certs. But it has no idea who really controls your DNS server or glue records.)

If you host your site at foo.example.com, then example.com can get a wildcard certificate for *.example.com that will be valid even if you have your own foo.example.com certificate and they can also change the A or AAAA record for foo.example.com to get a certificate with an HTTP challenge.

You could always petition browser vendors to pin your foo.example.com certificate, and thus override any tampering by the example.com DNS server. It is exceedingly unlikely they would do this for you.

TLS certificates these days only prove one thing: control over the DNS server at the time of provisioning.

There are no comments on this comment yet.