News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations by ChuckMcM on Friday February 04, 2011 @02:53PM (#2180872)
Given that Bing clearly uses the clickstream to influence its results pages, at what point to SEO folks run farms of machines in a network which resolve 'google.com' to a process that returns a fixed set of results for a given query?

Imagine this scenario, I create 10,000 VM instances of windows running IE8 with the Bing toolbar. I create a local host to 'stand in' for Google such that it emulates the actual Google site (one could even used scraped Google content) and for my 'target' query it returns my spammy results, and then my VM machine clicks on one of the spammy links.

It seems that Google's sting worked because their queries had small return rates, but with some resources it would seem a viable way to inject SEO love right into the bloodstream of Bing's ranking algorithm. As I see it, a whole new front just opened up for spammers.

--Chuck

Re:Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations by Natsu on Friday February 04, 2011 @03:23PM (#2181019)
You don't need VMs or a fake Google or anything that complex. That said, I will grant that it might be harder to detect or easier than reversing the protocol itself. Even so, take a look at what HN user angusgr posted in another thread:

http://projectgus.com/2011/02/bing-google-finding-some-facts...

I'll save you some reading and point out that this is the important part, the exchange with Bing:

http://projectgus.com/files/googlebing/seaport-trace.txt

I bet I could duplicate that with a few lines of Perl. Then I could feed Bing whatever I want, no VMs or clicking or DNS/hosts files to worry about. You might have to harvest a valid identifier (such as the one linked there) or do some figuring out so that you submit this to the right Microsoft IP.

If I were working for Bing, I'd start looking at hardening this a little, before the SEO people figure it out.

Re:Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations by dminor on Friday February 04, 2011 @03:14PM (#2180970)
Sure, but I'm hard pressed to think of a technique that the spammers wouldn't attempt to game. Search engines and spammers will probably always be in a perpetual arms race no matter what the methodology.
Re:Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations by encoderer on Friday February 04, 2011 @03:18PM (#2180990)
This is like gaming Google Suggest. You're going to need a lot of IP's because they're not idiots in Redmond OR Mountain View and it's pretty simple to detect behavior like that coming from a single IP.

If the spammer gets 10,000 IPs then more power to him. But there's probably more cost effective ways of black-hat SEO.

Re:Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations by Natsu on Friday February 04, 2011 @03:28PM (#2181048)
The spammers already control botnets of that size. They could duplicate the clickstream data with a few lines of code (it's a simple HTTP request feeding Bing the clicks; the only sticky parts are deciding which Bing IP to send them to and harvesting the per-computer ID it sends to Bing).

In short, this gives them a new service to sell when they rent out their existing botnet.

Re:Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations by encoderer on Friday February 04, 2011 @03:37PM (#2181094)
Then by your logic, they're already gaming Google Suggest. And with Instant Search, that's the holy grail. Who needs to optimize placement on a given keyword if you can just nudge users towards your desired keyword.

Or, what's more likely, is that the respective companies are aware of this very obvious vector and have attended to it.

Re:Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations by Natsu on Friday February 04, 2011 @04:04PM (#2181223)
What makes you assume that no one is attempting that?

Botnets are run off of the computers of ordinary, clueless folks, who might be real Bing users submitting real data in addition to whatever the botnet sends.

I've already linked to an analysis of the actual protocol data submitted by the toolbar and I can see obvious ways to copy and fake it.

If you use only the computers in your set that already have Bing, copy that unique ID and figure out what IP they're sending it to, your data will be identical to that sent by a real user.

At that point, you have to harden the protocol and hope it stands up to reverse engineering, or start spam filtering it (if they weren't already). Maybe they can do a good job of that, but it really lowers the quality of the data they're getting once enough people are feeding them garbage.

SEO types already set up thousands of spam websites to game PageRank. I don't see why this would be any different.

Re:Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations by ChuckMcM on Friday February 04, 2011 @04:21PM (#2181289)
I suspect that they are, and when you can simulate a million users doing what ever activity you want them to be doing then the impact on Google and lots of stuff will change.

Of course my favorite was the Amazon hack of repeatedly putting some item in a shopping cart and then adding in a bit of pr0n (or some other weird combination) so that Amazon would put the other item in their auto suggest product combination.

Re:Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations by kenjackson on Friday February 04, 2011 @03:14PM (#2180973)
Easy to circumvent. Spend 5 minutes thinking of how to do it. I suspect you'll think of at least a couple of ways.

The battle against spammers will continue to be cat and mouse game. And when one of your signals gets exposed, of course it will be a target.

There's nothing new here. In fact, I think most spammers already assumed that the toolbar clickthroughs fed into both Bing and Google toolbars. I did.

Re:Bing: Why Google’s Wrong In Its Accusations by fname on Friday February 04, 2011 @03:17PM (#2180987)
Well, Google should do nothing less than encourage people to use those spammy methods either stop the practice all together or force Microsoft to lessen the weight is uses for that particular signal.