News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:XMPP creator's "Locker" -- personal social media aggregat... by BarkMore on Friday February 04, 2011 @10:33AM (#2179720)
Why do you say that the author knows what he's doing? If your statement is based his work on Jabber (now called XMPP), then I am somewhat concerned. Several design decisions make Jabber difficult to implement with no benefit to the use cases. My previous comments about Jabber design decisions are here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2071652
Re:XMPP creator's "Locker" -- personal social media aggregat... by dminor on Friday February 04, 2011 @11:41AM (#2180025)
> Why do you say that the author knows what he's doing?

Jeremie Miller wrote a popular open source IM server and created a specification for the protocol which has been widely implemented in several different languages (Erlang, C, Python to name a few) for both client and server.

Many of the functions solved by XMPP (instant messaging, presence, federation) fit nicely into the distributed social network problem domain.

So that's why I have confidence that he knows what he's doing. Nits like "I don't like different XML namespaces" more or less miss the forest for the trees.

Re:XMPP creator's "Locker" -- personal social media aggregat... by BarkMore on Friday February 04, 2011 @12:08PM (#2180142)
I agree that my previous rant was about nits, but these nits add up and act as a barrier to entry to development in the space.

You mention that XMPP is widely implemented on the server, but only a few of the implementations are actually any good. To make matters worse, some of the best server implementations are written in fringe languages (Erlang for example).

I think that XMPP would be more successful if it had been more developer friendly.

Re:XMPP creator's "Locker" -- personal social media aggregat... by kwellman on Friday February 04, 2011 @01:57PM (#2180636)
Have you looked at telehash (http://www.telehash.org), a much more recent project by the same guy?

I'm impressed by how elegant the protocol is. I hate XMPP, but telehash gives me faith.