All I’m saying is it’s not reasonable to take such a stance selectively against findings that you personally disagree with.
Humans are complicated and unpredictable. Any field with 99% noise 1% signal requires different methodologies compared to, say, physics and computer vision ML. But you can still make some inferences and predictions (which, even if 100% "correct" will still only predict the 1% of signal, not the 99% of noise).
Not at all, at least not on my part. I think psychology is important. I am not convinced by the methodology though.
What I mean about "methodology" is the current trend of quantifying human personality traits, like that damned "agreeableness". I understand the aspiration to quantify the human personality (although I also personally find it a little off-putting) but it seems to me that it is very difficult to do with the tools with which it is being attempted. In fact, I think it's impossible to do what psychologists are trying to do, i.e. to do statistics on the human personality. Because the things you are trying to measure are impossible to define clearly and observe objectively since they have no physical substance.
So why do it at all? Why does psychology _need_ to have statistics on personality traits, when they are not really personality traits but complicated proxies for things we think may be representative of personality traits? Wouldn't the same effort be better spent on a different project? Can't psychology be taken seriously as a science without trying to do maths with things that don't really exist?
I am worried that even though skepticism is good, skepticism from people outside of a field can lead into a downward spiral of rejecting all conclusions made by serious practitioners of that field.
How many other endeavors would be impossible to undertake if people constantly disregarded the methods and practices of researchers and specialists within these disciplines?
At what point are we merely finding ourselves skeptical of research which contradicts our preconceptions?
How do we know when we are going too far in picking apart methodology that we don’t even understand that well?