Re:37-Year-Old Mom Spent Seven Days Online as an 11-Year-Old...
by pmoriarty on Saturday December 14, 2019 @02:32PM
(#21791610)
"It's a bit like leaving a fake gun on the street and then prosecuting a person who picks it up and tries to shoot somebody for attempted murder. Are you still guilty of a crime if you only think you were going to commit a crime? If someone lies to you that they are allergic to peanuts and you secretly give them peanuts is that attempted murder? If you download a song that you weren't aware is in the public domain, is that attempted copyright infringement?"
You bring up an interesting question, but your examples confuse the issue.
In your examples there are always real, intended victims: the person who was being shot at with the fake gun, the person who was being given peanuts, and the copyright holder are all the intended victim (despite the attempts failing due to misconceptions on the part of the perpetator).
In such cases, a better analogy might be to someone trying to rob a bank with a fake (or a broken) gun. It's pretty clear that in such a case they would go to jail for attempted robbery.
However, in the case where an adult pretends to be a child, there's no victim. There's real intent, but the victim is imaginary.
This is similar to laws making it a crime to possess cartoon child porn. Once again, there's no victim.
You bring up an interesting question, but your examples confuse the issue.
In your examples there are always real, intended victims: the person who was being shot at with the fake gun, the person who was being given peanuts, and the copyright holder are all the intended victim (despite the attempts failing due to misconceptions on the part of the perpetator).
In such cases, a better analogy might be to someone trying to rob a bank with a fake (or a broken) gun. It's pretty clear that in such a case they would go to jail for attempted robbery.
However, in the case where an adult pretends to be a child, there's no victim. There's real intent, but the victim is imaginary.
This is similar to laws making it a crime to possess cartoon child porn. Once again, there's no victim.