I used to keep my KeePass rule pretty liberal. Any 30-character length string would get generated. More than a few times I've had to either decrease the length or remove characters. I had to drop the length and keep it alphanumeric just to avoid the hassle. Plus, typing weird characters on a mobile device gets old fast (thankfully, KeePass exists on Droid, but boostrapping dropbox + KeePass is still annoying).
What's even worse is when password registration silently drops data. You'll register with one password, and attempting to log back in fails because the page that stored the password and the page that you log in on are using two (probably subtly) different decoding methods.
Here's some raw numbers:
Passwords: 336
Average password strength: 97.5 %
Average password length: 17.9 characters
Number of weak passwords: 3
(For reference, a 20 character password with specials is 100%, with just letters and numbers it comes in at 98%)
There are some warning signs that clue you in. Any of the following are good indicators that passwords are not being stored properly:
- Passwords emailed in plaintext on registration (minor flag - may be stored properly, but not good practice) - Passwords emailed in plaintext at any other time (definitely stored incorrectly) - Maximum length - Not allowed special characters - Including a " or ' in your password causes an error