Re:Linux Toolbox
by derefr on Saturday December 14, 2019 @12:57PM
(#21790896)
I know it’s completely irrational of me, but seeing something called a “zine” is offputting, since the central example of that term is usually a short political tabloid. (And it doesn’t even convey the information I expect from the “format noun”—zines are not usually illustrated!)
I’d really rather see these called what they are: educational graphic novels.
But I know why these end up getting called “zines”: it’s because there’re only a few major publishing cultures, sort of broken down along two axes (corporate vs. independent; fictional/author-driven vs. journalistic/editor-driven), and a person will end up enculturated with the terms of the publishing culture they learn the trade from. The “independent + editor-driven” culture calls everything they make “zines”, so that’s the term you need to use to communicate what you’re doing to your friends, if you’re a part of that culture.
I’d really rather see these called what they are: educational graphic novels.
But I know why these end up getting called “zines”: it’s because there’re only a few major publishing cultures, sort of broken down along two axes (corporate vs. independent; fictional/author-driven vs. journalistic/editor-driven), and a person will end up enculturated with the terms of the publishing culture they learn the trade from. The “independent + editor-driven” culture calls everything they make “zines”, so that’s the term you need to use to communicate what you’re doing to your friends, if you’re a part of that culture.