Re:Canada still wants to "discipline the use of the Internet"
by mschwar99 on Thursday February 03, 2011 @11:39PM
(#2178379)
I'd have more sympathy for this argument if government interference didn't play a large part in the construction of the status quo.
In Canada, government regulation and taxpayer money played a significant role in building the infrastructure. In the US, government granted monopolies built the infrastructure and still serve to squeeze out competition.
Government interference isn't a shiny new monster imposing itself on private sector infrastructure. Rather it has been a key player since the beginning and shaped the market in ways that need to be accounted for.
Re:Canada still wants to "discipline the use of the Internet"
by pyre on Friday February 04, 2011 @03:56AM
(#2178853)
> I don't believe in government interference.
But that's just it. Most of the telecoms in the US and Canada were built off of government subsidies, guaranteed (regional or nation-wide) monopolies, and/or guaranteed profits (see AT&T in the US). How can you then say that the government needs to be 'hand off' with a market that they've already skewed in favor of certain players? Not to mention that Bell in Canada is regulated this way by the CRTC because they control the last-mile telephone lines for DSL. Legally they are the only ones allowed to lay such lines, so should the government allow them to do whatever they want with their government-granted monopoly?
I don't believe in government interference.
Giving more incentive for better encoding is also a valid point. Netflix offered 10 million for better recommendations. I'd like to see them offer the same thing for better encoding.