News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Find the "bug" - Two equals Four - a mathematical "paradox" by pbhjpbhj on Thursday February 03, 2011 @11:08PM (#2178311)
It's 4am here and I need some sleep - choose 2 numbers from within the convergent range and do the same slight of hand with them. Clearly we can argue that x^^\inf = 4 has no convergence and so makes no sense but what if the equations are both in the converging region x € [e^−e, e^1/e] about [0.066, 1.445]:

  {1}    x^^\inf = 2
we've shown in the OP that x^2 = 2 is a solution.

Consider,

  {2}    x^^\inf = e^(2/e)
similarly to the OP we do

  {3}    x^ (x^^\inf) = x^ (e^(2/e))
but this is just

  {4}    x^^\inf =  x^ (e^(2/e))
and substituting on the left from {2}

  {5}    e^(2/e) = x^ (e^(2/e))
gives us (I think)

  {6}    x = e^ (2e^ (-1-(2/e))) ; ~~1.42267
Hence we've shown that

  {7}    2 ~~ 1.423
Which isn't as neat as 2==4 but equally troublesome.

There is no issue now with convergence is there (or there shouldn't be if I chose my numbers correctly)?

---

Notations

  ^^ : ascii version of Knuths up-arrow notation
  \inf : first countable infinity, aleph-0 
  € : in the range, it's really a Euro symbol, but close enough
  ~~ : approximately equal to
===

Solution

  y = x^2 
    = 9 give solution (3,9)
  y = x^2
    = 4 gives solution (2,4)
9=4?

They're just different points on the same curve ... doh! We're not showing that 9=4 we're showing that (3,9) and (2,4) are point solutions of y = x^2.

In the same way we have above 2 solution of y = x^^\inf.

There are no comments on this comment yet.