Re:If this project is dead, just tell us
by joshstrange on Friday December 13, 2019 @09:47AM
(#21782001)
I think this has less to do with "you don't want two versions of the same package running on a user's browser" and more to do with "when I clone a project and run npm/pip install I want it to be in a known state".
I don't use Python/pip much but as for npm: the problem is when your dependencies, direct or indirect (dependencies of dependencies), aren't "exact". You have something like "~1.2.3" or "^1.2.3". If every developer followed Semvar perfectly, never shipped regressions or new bugs when fixing a bug, and was always able to identify every breaking change then life would be perfect.
That is, however, not the world we live in. So a "lock" file respects your "fuzzy" versions ^/~ when you first run the npm install and then subsequent runs will install using the exact versions you downloaded the first time. This helps solve the "works me me"/"work on my machine" problems. The idea being if you can run it locally then the build server and production can also build/run your code.
I don't use Python/pip much but as for npm: the problem is when your dependencies, direct or indirect (dependencies of dependencies), aren't "exact". You have something like "~1.2.3" or "^1.2.3". If every developer followed Semvar perfectly, never shipped regressions or new bugs when fixing a bug, and was always able to identify every breaking change then life would be perfect.
That is, however, not the world we live in. So a "lock" file respects your "fuzzy" versions ^/~ when you first run the npm install and then subsequent runs will install using the exact versions you downloaded the first time. This helps solve the "works me me"/"work on my machine" problems. The idea being if you can run it locally then the build server and production can also build/run your code.