News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Gives Feds 1,500 Phone Locations in Unprecedented ... by thanhhaimai on Thursday December 12, 2019 @04:07PM (#21776474)
There are 2 issues in this:

1) Governments have law and warrants allowing them to get those data.

2) Companies with a lot of data are complying with those warrants.

The question is: can we fix #2 without fixing #1?

Re:Google Gives Feds 1,500 Phone Locations in Unprecedented ... by Kalium on Thursday December 12, 2019 @04:20PM (#21776612)
If you have data, or have any way to collect data, you can be compelled to hand it over.

The only real way to address #2 is by finding a way for companies to get all the value that comes from having this data without having to store or even process it.

Re:Google Gives Feds 1,500 Phone Locations in Unprecedented ... by salawat on Thursday December 12, 2019 @07:42PM (#21778128)
Why should these companies be entitled to the value of this data in the first place? The only reason they've gotten away with it this long is nobody understood what they were doing.

If you catch a child doing something they aren't supposed to... Say sneaking chocolate you hid in your closet, when you aren't looking, and you don't catch them doing it until a week later; are we seriously going to entertain that the right action on catching these misbehaving children is to let them keep/continue to reap the benefits of their ill-gotten gains? That's what allowing the continuation of this metadata collection sounds like it amounts to to me.

This pervasive invasion of privacy is not normal, never has been; nor should it ever be.

Not breaking the capability for companies to engage in surveillance capitalism represents an implicit acceptance of the nullity of Constitutional protections through indirections facilitated by Third Party Doctrine. That is not okay.

Re:Google Gives Feds 1,500 Phone Locations in Unprecedented ... by Kalium on Friday December 13, 2019 @12:31AM (#21779343)
> Why should these companies be entitled to the value of this data in the first place? The only reason they've gotten away with it this long is nobody understood what they were doing.

In many cases, they're using it to do things users like. Such as estimating commute times. Or do demand modeling and understand where they should upgrade cell networks.

You can offer services without these things - and please do! - but expect users to notice.

Re:Google Gives Feds 1,500 Phone Locations in Unprecedented ... by thanhhaimai on Thursday December 12, 2019 @07:51PM (#21778167)
You're not only catching a child sneaking chocolate. You're catching a child who are legally told by the police to go get the chocolate and hand it over, or else the child will be expelled from school.

Again, the question becomes: can you fix the child's behavior without fixing the fact that they are legally required to follow the police's words with no recourse?

Re:Google Gives Feds 1,500 Phone Locations in Unprecedented ... by NieDzejkob on Friday December 13, 2019 @05:37AM (#21780553)
Whether the chocolate is handed over doesn't really affect the sneaking itself being wrong.
Re:Google Gives Feds 1,500 Phone Locations in Unprecedented ... by breerly on Thursday December 12, 2019 @04:24PM (#21776644)
The real question is: is there a market for privacy-respecting tech services (think Apple's new stance on E2E privacy or laptops like Purism), such that consumers themselves can vote with their own dollars? The best way to protect and re-establish the right to personal privacy is through market demand, not legislation.
Re:Google Gives Feds 1,500 Phone Locations in Unprecedented ... by Kalium on Thursday December 12, 2019 @04:36PM (#21776788)
There is!

It's just so far proven to not be as large as one might hope. Consumers, when faced with services that don't offer them the features they want and higher prices, often think twice about preferring privacy.

There's a lot of money to be made by someone who finds a way to deliver the full-fat experience consumers want at the prices consumers are used to while also respecting privacy. Until then, I expect things like Purism and Protonmail to stay fairly niche concerns.

Re:Google Gives Feds 1,500 Phone Locations in Unprecedented ... by OrgNet on Thursday December 12, 2019 @07:28PM (#21778036)
you need to fix the laws no matter what.