Re:Thinking in React Hooks
by erikpukinskis on Friday December 13, 2019 @02:43AM
(#21779832)
> the only way to implement them (that I can think of) is messing with global state
What do you mean?
A regular global variable that is incremented each time you call useState/useEffect/etc and is resetted every time a new component starts rendering. This is why hook order must be maintained.
I have no idea where this is implemented in React, but in Preact it's a simple integer that is incremented:
https://github.com/preactjs/preact/blob/abc162c4d6442d5495f6...
I think there are other ways to implement them, such as treating the return of the render function as an AST and turning hooks into dumb factories, like a free monad. But considering the constraints they have (the need to maintain order) and the way it works (the fact the render function runs multiple times), I'm guessing it's just the same solution as Preact.
But on the other hand I agree that "keep the order!" is a very simple request for a feature that is so useful.