But it wasn't, so none of the rest matters.
On second thought don't bother answering that because again, this didn't happen in the EU so GDPR means absolutely nothing.
And since we are not talking about GDPR, who owns the personal data gathered by a company. The company or the person. Is there any argument in favor of the person having a right to access that data without paying?
This was the response Honda provided even without the GDPR applying.
The police could acquire a warrant to compel generation of the data, which Honda would comply with.
That's an interesting interpretation of GDPR. The car is not under the control of the owner, and so the location data isn't the owner's data.
I am also a bit curious of how the contract between the company and the device owner would transfer to the thief. The common way for companies to enable tracking is by having the user agree to it, but the thief clearly did not. Do a thief in EU have a GDPR case against a company if the owner track the stolen device through a service like this one?
Technically you can not track a person online. You can track an IP address, or a cookie, or an ID string in a database, but the server does not have eyes on the person behind the screen. Anyone can be behind the same IP address, people share accounts, browsers and devices. A operator can never be 100% sure if a data point identify you or anything about you.
But I don't think a judge would see that technical distinction. European courts already see mobile device location data as private data. So I ask you. What do you think a judge say about location data on peoples cars. Personal data just like mobile phones, or not?
Honda do not have a service where if you pay them they will track your car. Honda track car owners, and if you pay them will give you a copy of the data.
It is very questionable if user data is owned by the company that do the tracking. How would it look if Facebook withhold evidence that a victim requested in regard to information they themselves uploaded? Personally I found find it rather poor behavior if they extorted the victim before returning the victims personal information.
"Man got unknowingly data mined, company refuse to return private information to the victim of an ongoing crime." sounds like a story to me.
The key part of the article is that company is now saying that they did not track the car. If Honda never had the information then the argument that "Man didn't pay for service, company did not provide said service" make more sense.