Re:I stood up to my boss, then he got promoted
by basch on Wednesday December 11, 2019 @09:30PM
(#21768798)
>Companies need a few skeptics around to put the brakes on crazy ideas.
Absolutely. And not just crazy ideas, but maybe we'll intended ideas that are misaligned with each other or the overall goals and strategic roadmap. Too many autonomous silos that are all high functioning tend to not like a skeptic saying, "this is great in isolation but the sum of these parts don't fit coherently." They also don't like "this works, but it's an MVP at best, and isn't sustainable." Skeptics cognizant of technical debt, may meet unwelcomness in an org not willing to acknowledge it.
Companies need a few skeptics around to put the brakes on crazy ideas. I’ve seen far more half-baked money pit projects than risks that paid off in my career. In tech in general there is way too much optimism and ignoring inconvenient facts/constraints until disaster is clear. Someone who can EFFECTIVELY steer teams away from horrible decisions is worth their weight in gold.
In the OP’s case, he simply couldn’t effectively communicate this, and failed to notice the rampant nepotism up his management chain, but his heart was in the right place.