Re:Facebook Tells Barr It Won’t Open Up Encrypted Messages
by tptacek on Wednesday December 11, 2019 @07:22PM
(#21768238)
I don't know anything about this site, but if you navigate to the page labeled "doctor patient privilege":
https://definitions.uslegal.com/d/doctor-patient-privilege/
You'll find this helpful sentence:
In the U.S, the Federal Rules of Evidence do not recognize doctor-patient privilege.
I assume we're just nerding out for its own sake, because none of this has anything to do with my argument.
Re:Facebook Tells Barr It Won’t Open Up Encrypted Messages
by mistersquid on Thursday December 12, 2019 @02:19PM
(#21775261)
> You'll find this helpful sentence:
Thank you for clarifying.
Nerding out is a good way characterizing where we've gotten and--as I suspected earlier and am now certain--I don't understand what "Federal Rules of Evidence" means in the larger discussion of what kinds of disclosure would violate someone's constitutional rights.
<thinking face emoji>
With all due respect, I disagree with your assertion that "the federal rules of evidence [doesn't] recognize doctor-patient privilege".
SCOTUS's saying they
> simply hold that this record [Whalen] does not establish an invasion of any right or liberty protected by the Fourteenth Amendment. [0]
implies that there could be an invasion of a right protected by the Fourteenth Amendment, just not in this case.
While you are strictly correct that this is not a representation of doctor-patient privilege, SCOTUS's assertion that Whalen does not violate the Fourteenth Amendment suggests the possibility that some distribution of medical data could violate the Fourteenth Amendment.
As a side note, your assertion that the "same site says explicitly that it doesn't" recognize doctor-patient privilege is questionable. Would you mind pointing out which passage is explicit about this?
[0] https://healthcare.uslegal.com/doctor-patient-confidentialit...