Re:Bot can beat humans in multiplayer hidden-role games
by empath75 on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @09:57AM
(#21753031)
I think if I had guessed, I'd have thought this particular hidden role game was easily beaten with AI since the meaningful choices are so limited. Still, it was worth actually proving. I suspect something like one-night werewolf is unbeatable by ai since it's so heavily based on communication, and there's only one a single vote in the game, though..
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Bot can beat humans in multiplayer hidden-role games
by ggggtez on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @11:49AM
(#21754145)
ONUW harder than Avalon? Yeah I don't think so. While Avalon has ~15 team selections (for something like an average of 60 picks) plus over 100 yes/no votes, and ~20 fail/success votes... ONUW has pretty much no choices at all.
>one-night werewolf is unbeatable
You're asking the wrong question for starters. The AI does need to "beat" the game. It is being measured on whether it's better at the game than humans. And my experience is that most One Night games devolve into a 50/50 guess. An AI would be better at calculating the odds of the two proposed game states that the players can't actually differentiate. So the AI would surely trivially win more than human players.
Re:Bot can beat humans in multiplayer hidden-role games
by jawarner on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @11:53AM
(#21754185)
Using language is one of the team's future aims. I don't think it would be impossible, since outside of communication for reasoning / deduction purposes, every in-game action can be described in an obvious and unambiguous manner.