Re:The ego depletion saga demonstrates the importance of eff...
by AstralStorm on Monday December 09, 2019 @03:12AM
(#21741103)
It's doubly funny, because we actually have not enough of an idea how muscles do what they do... Even so far as immune system may be involved in their growth and strength adaptation.
Re:The ego depletion saga demonstrates the importance of eff...
by eru on Monday December 09, 2019 @06:22AM
(#21741778)
So it's an apt analogy after all.
Re:The ego depletion saga demonstrates the importance of eff...
by heracles on Monday December 09, 2019 @08:13AM
(#21742263)
I don't think so, no. Here is why: the basic behavior of muscles are decently well understood. For example why and how they contract and relax, and why they tire. We know of several reasons why muscles might malfunction. What is not well established is how and why muscles become stronger over time.
Compare this to for example ego depletion, and I would say that the analogy is not apt.
Re:The ego depletion saga demonstrates the importance of eff...
by eru on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @10:56PM
(#21759441)
Yes, true.
Re:The ego depletion saga demonstrates the importance of eff...
by lidHanteyk on Monday December 09, 2019 @10:54AM
(#21743640)
If one pumps iron, then one gets big and strong. What is the if-then for ego depletion? This entire fuzzy informal idea of common-sense causality is what is being wagered by these flimsy psychological concepts.
Re:The ego depletion saga demonstrates the importance of eff...
by feanaro on Monday December 09, 2019 @02:02PM
(#21745300)
If one exercises his willpower a lot†, then one has a progressively harder time doing so again shortly after‡. This is so because willpower is a finite, expendable resource which has to be renewed (through not exercising it).
† - for instance, by denying himself bad, tempting things
‡ - gives in to temptation
It's not flimsy at all, it just appears to be wrong.
I'd consider "it is like a muscle" a red flag when reading news/science.