Re:UBB overturned - Canada no longer biggest internet loser.
by gamble on Thursday February 03, 2011 @01:14AM
(#2173851)
They know what they're doing. The problem is that they're biased.
It's fundamentally the same issue that plagues financial regulation. The people who are the most qualified to understand the technological and regulatory issues are the most biased, because almost by necessity they're products of the same industry they're supposed to regulate.
Re:UBB overturned - Canada no longer biggest internet loser.
by noibl on Thursday February 03, 2011 @02:40AM
(#2174041)
On reading more about this I was depressed to see very little in the way of proposals to avoid the phenomenon, except (surprise! it's Stigler) don't regulate.
But I did find some interesting ideas at the end of this paper: http://www.icgg.org/downloads/Boehm%20-%20Regulatory%20Captu... (pp. 23-24)
Re:UBB overturned - Canada no longer biggest internet loser.
by redthrowaway on Thursday February 03, 2011 @03:18AM
(#2174100)
I don't think they need to be disolved, as in theory they perform a necessary function. Instead, merely sack all of the directors and hold parliamentary hearings for their replacements. Make it open and accountable, and you won't see the kind of patronage happening.
Re:UBB overturned - Canada no longer biggest internet loser.
by lurchpop on Thursday February 03, 2011 @03:10AM
(#2174082)
See "regulatory capture" wiki link below. What'll happen is what always does in the US. They'll assume the only people who know what they're doing are the regulatED, and there's your revolving door.
Pretty sweet choices: idiocy or corruption.
My vote would be for dissolution - maybe then they can create a regulator that actually employs people who understand what they're regulating.