For reference, French minimum wage is currently around 1200€ a month, with most workers earning around 1200-2000 because salaries are heavily index to the minimum.
It's one of the numerous issues with the pension system, pensions are comparable to full salaries.
I went on to skim the latest Pensions at a Glance [1] report from just last week, which drives your point home [2]:
> When voluntary private pensions are taken into account for the whole career in Belgium, Canada, Germany, Ireland, Israel, Japan, Mexico, New Zealand, the United Kingdom and the United States the average replacement, for these ten countries, is 58% for an average earner compared with 36% when only mandatory schemes are considered. The voluntary component has the largest impact on the replacement rate (more than 29 percentage points) in Ireland, the United Kingdom and the United States.
Note that this is also gross (before taxes) and since tax rates are lower (in the US at least) for this cohort during retirement, most particularly by not paying into Social Security (roughly 15% of employee plus employer contributions for people making less than $120k/yr) the numbers are understated. The section on net replacement sadly doesn't include voluntary pensions.
[1] http://www.oecd.org/pensions/oecd-pensions-at-a-glance-19991...
[2] https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org//sites/b6d3dcfc-en/1/2/5/4/ind...
On the other hand, cost of living is undoubtedly lower in France and Germany, especially healthcare. Yes, there's a government healthcare plan for seniors in the US, but IIRC it's not nearly as generous as the plans you see in western Europe.
This is weasel-speak. It’s strictly true, only because it’s worded in a way to exclude Social Security. Taken as a whole, US retirement safety net is more generous than the OECD average: https://www.etk.fi/en/the-pension-system/international-compa...
The above is OECD data, far more reliable than random assertions in the NYT.
Public and private pensions replace on average 70% of pre-retirement income for an average-income person, compared to 60% in France (and the OECD as a whole). Great Britain and Germany are even less. (And of course, because US incomes are higher to start with, US retirement income is even higher in absolute terms.
The average French pension payment is $1,500 per month, about the same as the average Social Security payment. But the average American worker gets about that much again in occupational pension. (See the break-down in the chart above, showing 100% of French pension coming from statutory pension, versus half of US pension coming from statutory pension.)