Sports works, but only because sports are extremely popular, with tens of millions of people enthusiastically participating on a regular basis, and accessible to anybody no matter their age and income. This is not true for, say, working at a law firm. You can’t take the best clerk from a pool of a thousand kids who have been clerking since elementary school. It’s either who you know, or who got good grades and test scores.
One would argue that this is the current status.
How objective are, e.g, IQ tests when I can take two different tests in a span of two hours and get from 128 to 146?
How my grades in Computer Engineering can be used to predict my performance as an Engineer in a country where 85% of the graduates would work in non-technical and more profitable fields?
If a company looking for a Quant gets someone with a Master in Math and a good tracking record knocking on their door, would they stop and ask to see if they can get someone with a PhD instead?
You are right that "proper evaluation takes time". What I am saying is that standardized tests should not count as proper evaluation.
> How objective are, e.g, IQ tests when I can take two different tests in a span of two hours and get from 128 to 146?
You can't take two proper WAIS-IV tests in two hours. In fact, unless you have been part of an unusual psychology study, you've probably never taken a real IQ test in your life. There are a lot of gimmicky free things on the internet that call themselves IQ tests but aren't predictive of anything.
As for the IQ test - it wasn't online and it wasn't a study, as far as I know - but I can totally concede that it was not a "real" IQ test.
Anyway, the story happened over 20 years ago. Part of the driving exam in Brazil included a "neuro-psychological evaluation" and the doctor flagged me for some extra tests. From what I remember I went to the clinic the next week, did one test, did the "neuro-technical" exam and was told to wait for an IQ test. When I got the form, it was the same as I got before originally (different order of questions) Long story short I asked why I was re-taking the test and I thought I "failed" somehow. They actually said they were not aware of the first one and later on found it.
Now that I think about it, perhaps it was some weird psychology test? :)
I am not asking for any utopia. What I am asking is "Instead of setting ourselves for failure every time coming up with some scheme for testing performance, why can't we just use actual performance on the activity that we want to evaluate candidates"?
It works for people in sports. It works for trade professions. It works for traders. It works for performers, entertainers, even entrepreneurs.
Why can't we have an educational system that does not put people on tracks to mold them and instead just coach them to follow whatever path they seem fit?