Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup
by umanwizard on Sunday December 08, 2019 @10:52AM
(#21736468)
I'm a non-native French speaker, but I had very similar thoughts: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16827225
(I've since been told that people in France do say "le menu", but I stand by the rest of that comment.)
The only added value I have from using Duolingo is getting some amount of practice actually constructing my target language but even then it's hugely limited because:
- You never have any context which makes the experience always completely artificial and makes it harder to get a feel or the language. IMO Duolingo would be 10x better if lessons followed (even very loosely) an internal story instead of just having random, often contrived sentences one after the other. Something as simple as recurring characters, simple common situations etc... It would make it a lot easier to have a mental model of the world you're talking about and it doesn't seem like it would complicate things heavily.
- The bulk of the practice involves translation exercises which is limiting and can even be counterproductive. A very important step towards fluency in any language is to stop translating and start constructing the language directly. I'm not a native English speaker but as I write these words I'm not translating a French internal monologue, I know what I want to say and I say it in English directly. It's faster and more natural that way.
- The killing blow is that those translation exercises are corrected by, as far as I can tell, some sort of complicated regexp engine. It's very common for a correct-but-unexpected solution to be rejected and when it gets reported it can lingers for years without being fixed. As such you start not to trust the correction given when you don't understand precisely why your sentence was wrong.
That last point is really frustrating. I'm a native French speaker and I tried finishing the "French for English speakers" tree using shortcuts to get an idea of the quality and I simply can't reliably unlock the checkpoints on my first try because some of my perfectly fine and idiomatic French sentences end up not fitting the regexp and be marked wrong.