News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by matt_the_bass on Friday December 06, 2019 @08:12PM (#21727757)
Interesting. I speak 2 foreign languages fluently (French and German) learned through formal training and immersion.

I go to the Netherlands at least once a year for work and can understand a little. So 2 weeks ago I started The DL Dutch lessons. I think they’re great! Certainly not a substitute for immersion, but I totally think that in 5 mins/day, I’ll be ready to converse a bit in a month or two.

Not to say that DL couldn’t be better, but for what I’m paying, Dutch lessons from DL seem to be worth my time.

Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by philsnow on Friday December 06, 2019 @09:23PM (#21728037)
Dutch is so similar to German though that you're not having to learn any of the "hard parts".

English speakers have a really hard time with German and Dutch piling up verbs at the end of giant clauses. You've already learned that when you became fluent in German.

I would probably piss a lot of people off if I were to call Dutch a "dialect" of German, but Dutch is definitely the closest language to German.

If you wanted to know whether Duolingo worked for language learning you'd be better off trying a language family that you're not already familiar with, but not one that's renowned for being particularly difficult like Japanese. Maybe Russian?

Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by xnyan on Friday December 06, 2019 @11:09PM (#21728407)
You’re preaching the truth here. I’m an English speaker who learned Russian and then taught russian for a decade or so. Duolingo is not going to help almost anyone significantly. What I mean by that is if you were a casual learner (nothing wrong with that) dedicating 5 to 30 minutes to duolingo a day, you will never be able to do anything other than say a few phrases or maybe pick out a few words of spoken russian here or there. Unless you are a language genius you will never be anything close to functional much less fluent without living in a 100% or close russian-speaking environment for a couple years at least. This is not me calling anyone dumb, russian is just really hard for almost all english speakers and requires an extreme amount of time and dedication. I don’t know if it’s true for other languages but I have a suspicion is that it is.
Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by jefftk on Friday December 06, 2019 @11:32PM (#21728488)
There State Department thinks Russian is hard for English speakers to learn, but has Arabic, Chinese, Korean, and others as even harder: https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Wikibooks:Language_Learning_Di...
Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by thaumasiotes on Friday December 06, 2019 @11:55PM (#21728551)
Russian is an Indo-European language, like English, and therefore has fundamentally similar grammar. Arabic, Chinese, and Korean are much more different (from English) than that.

That said, the State Department's estimation of the difficulty of Chinese is inflated by the difficulty of the writing system, which has nothing to do with the language itself. When people try to rank languages more-or-less objectively by how difficult they are to learn -- without reference to which other languages the student might already know -- Chinese and English are both common examples of the simplest class of languages. There is a theory in linguistics that seeks to explain this finding by reference to the history of "simple" languages -- they tend to be spoken across wide regions and learned by adults for pragmatic reasons. The theory goes that the influx of struggling adult learners changes the language to accommodate them.

Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by jefftk on Friday December 06, 2019 @11:57PM (#21728558)
Chinese would definitely be easier without the writing system (and I wish my two years of studying it had been verbal and pinyin only). But it's also tonal, which speakers of non-tonal languages generally have a really hard time with.
Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by crispinb on Saturday December 07, 2019 @11:39PM (#21734372)
> which speakers of non-tonal languages generally have a really hard time with.

Is this actually true? I only did some basic Mandarin, but its tonal system is so simple (and plainly transliterated) that it seemed like a non-issue to me. Done & dusted in a couple of hours or so, compared to the hundreds of hours needed for vocabulary, idioms etc. Not to mention the terrifying writing system. And I have no natural advantages, carrying a common disability (native monolingual English), and having only learned German previously.

Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by thaumasiotes on Saturday December 07, 2019 @12:29AM (#21728682)
But English is a tonal language; that hypothetical problem can't be a source of extreme difficulty for English-speaking learners.

(I do have problems with English tones interfering with my attempts to speak Chinese, but that's really not the same problem as "My language doesn't use tones, so I don't know how to produce them". I do know how; I just don't have good control over them.)

Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by yorwba on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:26AM (#21729499)
English doesn't have falling-rising contours like the Mandarin third tone, so there's at least the difficulty of having to learn a new category of pitch change. I do wonder whether e.g. Mandarin speakers have similar difficulty acquiring the different contours of e.g. Cantonese. Intuitively, I'd expect it to get easier the more different categories one can already distinguish.
Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by thaumasiotes on Saturday December 07, 2019 @05:52AM (#21729577)
English does have such a contour, in the fairly special case of the three-tone "I don't know" sequence. (On the "know".)
Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by xnyan on Saturday December 07, 2019 @11:18AM (#21731007)
I won’t argue with you there, I’m not qualified to compare anything but russian and english (and maybe Ukrainian). I’ve heard others say the same thing you are and my research agrees with that assessment. A friend of mine is fluent in both Russian and Arabic and English and would agree that Arabic was harder. When living in Ukraine I knew a lot of people from the Middle East studying medicine in Kharkov and they mostly all learned Russian very well, I can’t say the same for my english speaking students learning russian in East Ukraine.

I am biased so I personally think Russian is a fantastic language both to speak and read. In addition to the literature and people, russian seems to be the most common non-English language after chinese on the internet which lets me see some corners of the web I would not otherwise.

Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by matt_the_bass on Tuesday December 10, 2019 @06:58AM (#21751654)
Oh I agree with you that Dutch is very similar to German. So far it seems like a “simplified German with mostly English word order and a funny accent”. I agree that’s an advantage for a Germans speaker.

But my point was that Duolingo is offering me value. Yes there are other tools. Yes I think language learning can’t be achieved with our interactions. But at the same time I think that duolingo Has been a good use of my time so far. I don’t have 20 minutes at a time to take a class but I do have 3 minutes 6-7 times a day when I can pull out my phone and practice.

Re:Duolingo becomes first VC-funded $1B Pittsburgh tech startup by sjy on Friday December 06, 2019 @09:34PM (#21728074)
I’ve studied French (easy for an English speaker), Japanese (hard but I already knew the basics from school) and Russian (hard and I didn’t know the alphabet when I started) on Duolingo. I assure you I have learned some things about those languages, even if I would have learned more if I spent the same amount of time in class. Of course, some of the courses are better than others, and languages that are less like your own are harder to learn, but that doesn’t mean you can dismiss the experiences of those who have used the app to build their knowledge of easy languages.