News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nate Silver: How Much Does Bing Borrow From Google? by gojomo on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @05:11PM (#2172427)
There are multiple mechanisms by which Google's rankings will diffuse out to other services.

For example, lots of SEO and normal research studies the top Google results, or keywords revealed from referrer info and other logs, and then mimics those results elsewhere on the web, including outlinking to top results found via Google.

So anything prominent in Google's results will be echoed elsewhere in crawlable form, and probably associated with the same terms by which it was found at Google. Then those once-unique results will 'later appear' in other resources.

You can't be the dominating giant of the industry – the "single point labeled G connected to 10 billion destination pages" (as Blekko's Skrenta calls Google) – and not have this leakage happen. It goes with the territory.

Re:Nate Silver: How Much Does Bing Borrow From Google? by noibl on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @05:23PM (#2172479)
Rankings analysis always starts with keywords of interest, even though Google can be used to identify keywords by relation. Referrer logs seeding outside sources with gibberish keywords that literally nobody is interested in? That's a stretch.
Re:Nate Silver: How Much Does Bing Borrow From Google? by gojomo on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @05:31PM (#2172507)
I'm not saying this is specifically how the gibberish Google probes landed in Bing; I'm saying this is a way that, even for popular queries, Google's ranking judgements and unique results are going to slowly diffuse out over time, and be echoed elsewhere, even without URL-trail mining (which shortcuts/supercharges the process).
Re:Nate Silver: How Much Does Bing Borrow From Google? by noibl on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @05:39PM (#2172548)
Fair enough. I agree that naive indexers will make lots of crude and meaningless associations. I don't think Bing falls into that category though.