News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spain planning on going ahead with ‘Google tax’ despite U... by ericmay on Thursday December 05, 2019 @12:51PM (#21714434)
A couple of points:

1) If you pay tax where you do business do you pay tax on global profits there? For example, France’s new law taxes 3% of global revenue if you do more than €28m in business in the country. Should it be taxed on 3% of global revenue or on the exact amount of business it does in France?

2) If BMW sells a car in the US, do we tax BMW global for doing business in the US at the 21% tax rate?

“ The levy designed by Spain included a tax rate of 3%, which would be applied to certain digital services from tech giants whose global revenues exceed €750 million and whose earnings in Spain are greater than €3 million.”

So let’s say the US goes back to Europe and says ok Europe, all of your best industries/companies face a 3% tax if you do more than a million dollars worth of business. How would those companies react? Think they might press their governments to do something about it?

I’m not a fan of tax-avoidance or anything, but I hardly think this proposed solution is fair, or won’t elicit a significant response from the US. It’s protectionism - so call it that and make sure you are railing against the internet about it like you do when Trump does random tariffs.

Spain doesn’t export a lot to the US maybe? Ok then the US can just pick and choose Eurozone members to arbitrarily tax. That’s what I’d do. 15% tax on global revenue for European cars sold in the US. Why not?

Re:Spain planning on going ahead with ‘Google tax’ despite U... by antaviana on Thursday December 05, 2019 @03:55PM (#21716385)
Regarding 1), it is a 3% on France revenue, not global revenue.
Re:Spain planning on going ahead with ‘Google tax’ despite U... by codedokode on Thursday December 05, 2019 @04:01PM (#21716451)
> If BMW sells a car in the US

Aren't there import tariffs and sales tax in US?