Re:Fight back against Google AMP (2018)
by tyingq on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:06PM
(#21707724)
Let's try this...It isn't me anyone needs to convince. An appeal to authority is appropriate when said authorities control the browsers needed for the proposal to succeed.
One of those 6 labels is "non-harmful". It's it isn't harmful, that seems right. Here's the legend:
"Mozilla does not see this specification as harmful, but is not convinced that it is a good approach or worth working on."
Mozilla didn't choose that label.
My view is that the proposal was driven by a desire to make AMP less icky. It looks like it could have broader benefit if the concerns Mozilla outlined are addressed. I am skeptical Google will do that.
As for your characterization of yourself as "well informed" and me as, er, something else...really? Was that necessary?
Let's try a different approach. How about this: I've carefully read over both the spec itself and everything Apple and Mozilla have to say on the matter (that I was able to find anyway), and have come to an informed conclusion: both Apple and Mozilla are wrong. (That's actually a rather poor, oversimplified summary of my position. But no moreso than "harmful" is a poor, oversimplified summary of Mozilla's position.)
You are making an argument from authority. I consider myself sufficiently well informed on this particular topic to be making arguments based on facts and reason. I don't find you repeatedly citing a one-word summary of Mozilla's position on the matter (which is actually quite nuanced, and not at all able to be summed up by a single word) to be particularly convincing.