the camps serve no productive purpose, yet here we are with a bunch of them in the country anyway.
If these people attempting to enter were simply turned around and immediately deported, the same people claiming that these are “actual in real life holocaust-2.0-about-to-happen concentration camps” would be upset about the “barbarism” of this stance instead of holding them while they wait for hearings.
[0] https://www.nybooks.com/daily/2019/07/01/an-open-letter-to-t...
“...unequivocally rejecting efforts to create analogies between the Holocaust and other events, whether historical or contemporary...”
[0] https://nypost.com/2019/06/24/us-holocaust-museum-denounces-...
[1] https://www.timesofisrael.com/us-holocaust-museum-rejects-na...
[2] https://www.jta.org/quick-reads/us-holocaust-museum-reiterat...
You are claiming that this letter says something that it, quite literally, does not.
You seem to be confusing concentration camp - you know, any holding facility whatsoever - with death camps. They are not synonymous.
The conditions and provisions those children are getting in those buildings are better than what they would be getting in the desert and with the adults they came with.
1/3 girls dragged across the border are raped.
You can't be mad at the building but be complacent with the root of the problem.
> You can't be mad at the building but be complacent with the root of the problem.
I am mad at the root of the problem, which is why I'm disappointed that this administration continues to undercut foreign aid efforts to improve the conditions in central American countries.
No, it isn't. You can file the application no matter how you entered or what your current status is, but that doesn't post-facto make an illegal entry suddenly legal.
Asylum seekers may be excused for illegal entry into the US. An asylum seeker can even use a fake passport to get through customs to apply for asylum: see Akinmade v. INS as an example.
This doesn't make the border crossing "explicitly legal," as you claimed, it just means that if you are granted asylum (which, I venture, most applicants are not, since the scope of asylum law is quite narrow), then your illegal entry will be disregarded.
Does that happen automatically when someone just asks for asylum? Or does asylum have to actually be granted first?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_and_Nationality_Ac...
(Also, ninth circuit court holdings are only applicable in the ninth circuit.)
Most of the crossers aren't "technically" asylum seekers and more like economic migrants trying to look for a better life. They probably know this and so hide from border officials.
So one side of this debate wants to "include" economic migrants, and the other doesn't. If we can resolve this particular point, we can cut through all the hyperbole and emotion regarding the topic.
"[...] a place in which large numbers of people, especially political prisoners or members of persecuted minorities, are deliberately imprisoned in a relatively small area with inadequate facilities, sometimes to provide forced labor or to await mass execution.[..]"
First of all, border crossers are neither a political class nor a persecuted minority (again, another abused nebulous term that means different things to different people). E.g. I'm a white male, and I happen to be a minority where I live. This place even has laws specifically designed to target us, yet here we're supposedly a "ruling minority" or something. Definitely not the same meaning geographically, but even more so politically.
Second. They're not forced to provide manual labor. Best I can tell is that it's voluntary, comparable to existing detention centers for citizens and they get some token pay in return.
Third. They're not there to await mass execution. At this point, using "concentration camp" in the normal "this is a bad thing to do to people" sense is quite hyperbolic. They're there waiting for court and/or deportation. I mean, what else do you want ICE to do if that is their current legal obligation to do? Must they say "screw it, the humane beds/cells are full, let's let those guys run right past us."
I think the above is from the Oxford dictionary according to Google.
Here is the definition from Merriam Webster, too:
"a place where large numbers of people (such as prisoners of war, political prisoners, refugees, or the members of an ethnic or religious minority) are detained or confined under armed guard —used especially in reference to camps created by the Nazis in World War II for the internment and persecution of Jews and other prisoners"
No, it doesn't, and even to the partial extent it does, is HIGHLY disingenuous. Here is the definition of concentration camp:
a place where large numbers of people, especially political prisoners or members of persecuted minorities, are deliberately imprisoned in a relatively small area with inadequate facilities, sometimes to provide forced labor or to await mass execution. The term is most strongly associated with the several hundred camps established by the Nazis in Germany and occupied Europe in 1933–4
By calling it a concentration camp you are implying that migrants engaged in border crossings are political prisoners or persecuted minorities, which is flatly false. Furthermore you are loading the comment with obvious semantic baggage of the Nazi concentration camps and their horrors in order to massively exaggerate the blame and moral culpability of anyone associated with them.
[1]: The tribunal hearings are effectively a kangaroo court -- there are cases of pre-teen children being asked to make a legal defense without an attorney or their parents.
[2]: https://eu.freep.com/story/news/local/michigan/2019/11/27/ic...
So my question remains. When all of these agencies are practising legal entrapment, would you agree never to provide services to them?
Trump has asked for additional funding for supplies including beds and toothbrushes. Trump as the head of the executive branch is in charge of ICE. So ICE has effectively asked for additional supplies. Congress hasn't done anything about that. It is not ICE's fault.
>entrapping legally-resident students into violating their visa conditions by setting up a fake university
This was started under Obama. Surely if this was a big issue then Github shouldn't have gotten into the contract in the first place.
Was that before or after the public outcry over it? Also, there's the separation of parents and children which he definitely hasn't done anything about.
> This was started under Obama.
How is that a defense? It's still unethical.
Trump advocated additional funding for ICE while he was still a candidate. As far as I know he did not specifically mention beds, toothbrushes, soap, etc until he was in office. Since practically nobody cared about the poor conditions of ICE detention centers while Obama was in office Trump may not have even know that they did not have enough supplies. I am unsure if Trump would have advocated for additional supplies if he had known.
>Also, there's the separation of parents and children which he definitely hasn't done anything about.
What is he supposed to do? There are 5 different things he can do and none of them are good.
1. Release parents and children into the US regardless of legal status.
2. Keep children in jail with their parents.
3. Separate children by sending them back to their country.
4. Separate children by placing them somewhere in the US (either with family or social services).
5. Send the entire family back to their country they came from.
A lot of the who make your point say to release them into the US. The problem is it would put a large strain on the welfare system. Even Bernie Sanders and others like him have explicitly said that it is not practical with the current system.
So what would you do with the children?
>How is that a defense? It's still unethical.
I am saying if setting up fake universities and entrapping people was a big deal then the deal between Github and ICE never should have been entered into. Github did not start the deal under Trump. They started it under Obama. Almost nobody seemed to care when Obama did the same thing Trump is doing. The media wasn't talking about it multiple times a day. People were not making speeches while crying about how awful it was. It feels like people only care now that Trump is in power. It was well known what was happening with ICE (and INS before them). It feels so political. That is all I was trying to convey.
> This government agency is actively committing numerous crimes and human rights violations, in contravention of both US and international law. ICE conducts random violent raids throughout the United States, invades communities and workplaces with military equipment, detains busses and trains, and arrests people solely on the basis of their perceived nationality, skin color, or native language. Their agents lurk outside of schools in order to abduct the children of immigrants and force their families to surrender themselves into custody. ICE imprisons people in deplorable and unsanitary conditions and denies them medical care. They separate the children they imprison from their families and offer them for adoption by others via agencies with shady histories. ICE agents subject both the adults and children they imprison to horrific physical, psychological, and sexual abuse. They continue to commit these heinous acts in defiance of multiple judgments issued by US courts and condemnations by humanitarian organizations. Many people, including children, have now died in their custody.
I understand some people just don't like immigrants for many reasons outside of racism/bigotry/xenophobia. Economics and culture being two of many reasonable reasons to dislike immigration.
But having a wing of government acting like the taliban does nothing but empower actual racist/xenophobic/bigoted individuals to enact their deepest sadistic fantasies on these people. This is clearly not simply immigration enforcement.
I support immigration enforcement. I do not support ICE. Supporting ICE is supporting and empowering racism and xenophobia full stop.
Can you state what immigration enforcement you support? The level of hyperbole in your response indicates that you see all immigration enforcement as cruel and unusual.
ICE is simply trying to pull weeds when what you need to do is kill the root. Illegal immigrants come because of many reasons, but primary is to cheat the system that legal immigrants use to find a better life.
If you make the job opportunities sparse, you kill the desire at the root. Open borders is a problem, especially in today's climate change world but it exists because people are willing to employ illegals for below market rates. It's the worst of all worlds for all, except the employer who gets off with cheap labour.
If we do this, we'll finally see if the xenophobes put their money where their mouth is and take back the jobs illegal immigrants have "stolen" from them.
Source? Citation?
> Supporting ICE is supporting and empowering racism and xenophobia full stop.
No, it isn't.
In the face of all the horrific reports coming from those jail cells, tell me how actively supporting ICE is not. Hell, name even one government facility where numerous children have died because of neglect and abuse at the hands of government officials.
And again, I can guarantee that illegal immigration will not stop because of ICE's shock tactics. It's just another hoop to jump through. Some of these people escaped the clutches of cartels, for chrissake. You underestimate the resolve of people who find no hope in their current situations.
I said in another comment the way to stop illegal immigration is via jailing business owners that hire illegal immigrants. This is just the war on drugs all over again. You're jailing the users, not the pushers.
All ICE does is enable actual racists and bigots (https://www.nytimes.com/2019/07/15/us/politics/border-patrol...) to enact their fantasies of making immigrants lives a living hell.