News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:23AM (#21701042)
The idea that human intelligence is defined by skill in board games or terminal chat is a hilariously inept failure of human intelligence.

Turing's test is useless for real AGI, because human-level intelligence is embodied. That means a human-equivalent AGI has to be able to improvise solutions with physical objects, parse body language, generate body language, understand social and cultural expectations in different situations, and do all of this while recognising and generating everyday speech in at least one human language.

These are all defining basic skills for humans. Literally every school age and over human can do them at a basic level. And gifted or exceptional humans can take these "simple" challenges to very advanced levels.

A chatbot doesn't come close to approaching them. Nor does a chess-bot or a go-bot. Nor does an equation solver.

AGI will fail until AI research stops trying to build a better AI research nerd, and starts trying to understand what applied human intelligence looks like in the wild.

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by tialaramex on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @06:48AM (#21701380)
> Literally every school age and over human can do them at a basic level

This is the other side of the same coin. No. These "defining basic skills" aren't defining anything except if you're going to be a fascist who eradicates people that defy their beliefs about embodiment.

Understanding social expectations is tricky and lots of humans can't do this at all. They require lifetime care as a result, but they are still definitely human and there's no reason to believe they lack general intelligence although it may be stunted if their problems make it hard to undertake activities that let intelligence thrive.

Although human infants do try to bootstrap language, the bootstrap process will not spontaneously produce a working human language from zero in the absence of exposure to existing human language. Humans brought up without language (typically through extreme circumstances because doing this experimentally would be unethical) create a proto-language but not a full-blown human language. We _think_ that a few generations of humans otherwise unexposed to external culture would turn this into a full-blown human language through some mechanism akin to creolisation but we can't check because - as mentioned - it would be grossly unethical. So, there definitely are humans (though not many) who don't recognise and generate "everyday speech" even taking that very broadly to include sign and the procedure used to talk to deaf-blind people.

Elderly people also often cease to be able to generate speech, or give no sign they continue to understand it, while continuing to apparently be intelligent.

Re:AGI Has Been Delayed by paganel on Wednesday December 04, 2019 @05:35AM (#21701093)
> AGI will fail until AI research stops trying to build a better AI research nerd, and starts trying to understand what applied human intelligence looks like in the wild.

I fully agree with your comment, just wanted to point out that imho the quoted paragraph also says a lot about how most of today's researchers totally disregard "human studies" (the "human intelligence in the wild" that you mention), as long as it's not quantifiable/turned into mathematics it has almost no value for them. Which, of course, it's a total bastardization of what even science-oriented people like Popper were writing about.