But this is only valid until it comes to maximize profits. Then suddenly they are (heavy handed) editors.
Can you provide an example of Facebook ever claiming they are just "dumb pipes" and how that claim had any material impact on their business? Are you suggesting Facebook is potentially guilty of false advertising?
Broadcast Television dealt with this issue for decades. You can say they made mistakes, but they did a pretty good job for a long time.
Someone will say, but there is too much material on Facebook (or Youtube or etc) to exert that kind of editorial control. Fine. Only check (and take responsibility for) things you promote into my feed. If someone I know wants to send me a crazy video or message, that is free speech. If Twitter, Youtube, Facebook puts information into my feed I didn't ask for, they should take responsibility for it.
OK, fine. But then they need to completely stop editorializing and remove all algorithmic treatment and active censorship of posts, news and ads.
As long they're not doing that they are editorializing and are not a dumb pipe. Something they very much like to claim, when it's convenient to them.
I see this huge hypocracy with tech companies in general and deem it completely unacceptable.
You just can't have it both ways and being logically conistent with your arguments at the same time. And that's exactly what they're trying to do.
Social media companies should not be the arbiters of truth. I don't want Facebook or Google deciding for us what truth is. If the speech is illegal, like defamation or direct calls to violence, it should be taken down. Other than that, falsehood should be countered with truth rather than removal.
If you look at Fox News vs CNN, you'll see completely different versions of 'truth'. Any 'fact' these days can be labeled as fake news or a conspiracy theory. Both sides are doing it. But it would be far worse if there were only one version rather than two.