News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Paradox of Corporate Taxes by patio11 on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @02:55AM (#2169498)
Corporations don't pay taxes any more than the government pays for healthcare: people pay for both. Every dollar paid in taxes is a dollar taken from a real, flesh-and-blood human being. (And, of course, transferred to a real human being. The California corporate tax, for example, is a wealth transfer from anyone beneficially owning a Californian corporation to Californian public employees, who are - far and away - the largest beneficiary of Californian taxes.)
Re:The Paradox of Corporate Taxes by gjm11 on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @05:34AM (#2169759)
Are those Californian public employees paid for doing nothing? If not, then the California corporate tax is a "wealth transfer" to the same extent as any salary payment is a "wealth transfer".

Those public employees are doing things like teaching schoolkids and collecting the garbage and making roads. If they aren't ludicrously overpaid (I've heard stories suggesting that some public employees are ludicrously overpaid, but what's the situation in general?) then what's actually happening is that corporate taxes are transferring ... well, maybe "wealth" sounds too specifically like money, so let's say "well-being" or "welfare" or something ... from beneficial owners of Californian corporations, to schoolkids and homeowners and road users and so forth.

Maybe that's a good thing, maybe not, but it's not quite the same as just taking business-owners' money and handing it to public employees.

(Much the largest expenditure in the California state budget is education. I think a high-school math teacher in California earns about $60k/year. Doesn't sound lavishly overpaid to me.)

Re:The Paradox of Corporate Taxes by joeag on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @11:58PM (#2173681)
Unfortunately there are also fireman, police, city managers, political assistants, etc. who make $150,000 to $450,000 a year, and will retire with 90% of that salary per year for LIFE (I kid you not). That's where all CA taxes (corporate, property, sales, you name it) will end up going. The reason why is that the unions control lots of voters, and politicians that wanted to get elected became beholden to those unions and gave them contracts 20 years ago that the state can't afford.
Re:The Paradox of Corporate Taxes by iwwr on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @06:49AM (#2169906)
Certain categories of public employees would do less damage by doing nothing.
Re:The Paradox of Corporate Taxes by toddh on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @11:07AM (#2170698)
Corporations get numerous specific legal benefits enforced by the power of the state. Nobody is required to organize as a corporation, so the benefits must be worth the cost. Corporations pay taxes because they get benefits nobody else gets. These should be give for free? That doesn't make sense. The real crime is it's the little guy who can't setup the multi-national tax-swaps or invest billions in "inefficient investments" that end up paying the top 39%.
Re:The Paradox of Corporate Taxes by 2arrs2ells on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @03:26AM (#2169543)
I'm not sure your comment has any substance to it.

I could reframe it "Every dollar paid in taxes is a dollar given to a real, flesh-and-blood human being" and the same facts point to the opposite conclusion.

I hope that the HN crowd isn't so ignorant as to think that corporations aren't made up of real people.

Re:The Paradox of Corporate Taxes by ecuzzillo on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @03:38AM (#2169560)
Yeah, but the real flesh-and-blood human beings receiving the dollars, his point is, are not really people whom most people are all that interested in randomly giving dollars to, like starving people in Africa; they're government bureaucrats who often end up serving to make dollar-givers' lives more difficult.
Re:The Paradox of Corporate Taxes by gjm11 on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @05:41AM (#2169778)
Except that he only made it sound that way by pretending that the people being paid with those tax dollars are taking the money for doing nothing, whereas in fact they are, e.g., teachers and policemen and firefighters, and the government is handing that money to them in exchange for doing their jobs, and their jobs do in fact involve providing public services.

In other words, exactly what taxes are meant to be used for.

Now, of course it's possible that California is employing incompetent people to do those things, or that it's prioritizing them badly, or that its bureaucratic overhead is much bigger than it should be. But (1) Patrick didn't offer any sort of evidence for any of those things, or even say them, and (2) those things, if true, aren't problems with taxation but with other functions of government. (Unless they're incurable, so that anything paid for by taxes is inevitably going to be done badly; but, living as I do in a country where all sorts of important things are done quite competently using money raised from taxes, I find that difficult to believe.)

Re:The Paradox of Corporate Taxes by jokermatt999 on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @01:04PM (#2171271)
Do you have absolutely anything to back up what you're saying, or are you just stating your prejudices?
Re:The Paradox of Corporate Taxes by borism on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @07:45AM (#2170010)
I totally agree with you that his comment adds 0 to the discussion, but it will be upvoted anyway because hey, it's coming from HN authority, right?