News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Four fired workers file charges against Google by stronglikedan on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:54AM (#21694040)
Your weirdly aggressive tone aside, I'll just say that I don't work with the smartest of people, but even still, almost everyone here with a company phone does choose to keep a separate private phone, namely due to perfectly valid policies like the one being discussed. She chose not to, and while she is a victim, it's only by her own choosing, so she is definitely solely to blame.
Re:Four fired workers file charges against Google by el_s3v3n on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:27AM (#21693778)
Yes, they did choose. It's a very voluntary and conscious decision to say "I am going to use my corporate device for personal needs, too."

Google provides a number of things. Food, showers, vehicles, lockers. You may CHOOSE to use these things or you may CHOOSE not to.

If you CHOOSE to store all your personal docs on your work laptop, and the laptop goes up in flames, who do you blame then?

Victim shaming is one thing, but being a naive child is another. A wise, rational, level-headed adult understands that company-owned assets are not suitable for personal use. Period.

Re:Four fired workers file charges against Google by dehrmann on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:39AM (#21693897)
And this is a case where the choice wasn't coercive--the alternative is carrying two phones and paying $60 per month for a personal plan.
Re:Four fired workers file charges against Google by officeplant on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @02:20PM (#21695624)
Who says you have to spend so much when affordable $15 a month prepaid plans exist? (and thats unlimited talk/text and 3GB of data) Cheap personal phone and plan. Problem solved.
Re:Four fired workers file charges against Google by javajosh on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @12:02PM (#21694142)
It's 1950 and you get a company issued wallet. They expect it back, and all it's contents, if you leave for any reason. You work for a few years, and to make life a little more pleasant you put a picture of your mom in the wallet. And then one day, unexpectedly, you're fired. And your boss says, "Give me the wallet, now." You hand it over, and then remember the photo. You ask for it. Then your boss says, "No. We keep the wallet and it's contents. You agreed to that. Now get out."

Tell me, how is this situation different?

Re:Four fired workers file charges against Google by el_s3v3n on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @12:14PM (#21694267)
Because even back then, in simpler times, only a simpleton would discard the personal wallet they had prior to taking the job and exclusively use the company-issued wallet.
Re:Four fired workers file charges against Google by Infinitesimus on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @12:17PM (#21694296)
Did you put that picture in, knowing full well that the company will take the wallet and contents?
Re:Four fired workers file charges against Google by scarface74 on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:13AM (#21693631)
Who doesn’t know that using a company device for personal use is a bad idea? We aren’t talking about a Luddite here.
Re:Four fired workers file charges against Google by notyourwork on Tuesday December 03, 2019 @11:23AM (#21693742)
It’s made very clear when you enroll in MDM what the implications are. If we can’t trust tech people to own decisions like this than how do we expect tech illiterate to understand. These are software engineers at Google, not someone’s grandma who did what the cell phone guy at the mall said to do. Come on.