Re:But now: US viewers seek Al Jazeera coverage
by jhamburger on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @01:05AM
(#2169246)
When the subject is feminism, is it correct to say "straw man" or "straw person"?
Re:But now: US viewers seek Al Jazeera coverage
by Alex3917 on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @01:12AM
(#2169269)
A straw man is a type of logical fallacy. I'm not making any argument; rather, I'm merely reporting a (possibly flawed) observation, so I don't really see how logical fallacies are relevant.
Re:But now: US viewers seek Al Jazeera coverage
by ericd on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @04:00AM
(#2169597)
A lot of people on HN really, really like claiming "strawman" on others. I've almost never heard it used outside of HN.
Re:But now: US viewers seek Al Jazeera coverage
by nitrogen on Wednesday February 02, 2011 @11:22AM
(#2170778)
One tends to hear mention of logical fallacies in any intellectually-focused forum, not only HN. HN happens to be intellectually-focused, so the straw man and other fallacies will see frequent mention here.
However, this is unrelated to the grandparent comment, which was (perhaps facetiously) primarily discussing feminism and political correctness, not logical fallacies.
The basic argument, if I undertand it correctly, is that women should be able to achieve success in any given field by doing things that women are stereotypically interested in. So, for example, they would consider Silicon Valley to be patriarchal because there isn't any role for women who only read People and US Weekly.
I know someone will accuse me of being sexist, but this was actually the consensus from the Women and Entrepreneurship class I took in college, albeit it wasn't phrased in exactly this way.