Re:Is true hacking dead? What we lost
by zozbot234 on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:08AM
(#21682366)
If it's easier to do it on Unity, the way to go is to improve Godot until it's even easier to use than Unity! :-) And the actual point of using something open like Godot is to raise kids who will internalize the fact that they could make not just their games, but their game engines as well - indeed, that nothing is 'magic' and anything can be thoroughly understood from first principles if one cares enough to do so. Every hacker knows this already, of course - but normies don't, even though that's the most useful lesson that 'hacking' can teach.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Is true hacking dead? What we lost
by marcus_holmes on Monday December 02, 2019 @01:14PM
(#21685059)
I get that. But again it's an endless stair of complexity and tool-building. So you can't write your game because first you need to improve your game engine! But your game engine needs improved graphics drivers, so you need to work on that! But graphics drivers only work well on a decent compositor, so you need to work on that! But a decent compositor needs a kernel architecture that actually does what it says on the tin, so you need to work on that!
At what point do you say "enough!" and start writing the game not the tool? I say that for a kid starting out, that point is right at the start.
IF they get good at games coding, THEN by all means get them interested in Godot and helping to write a new games engine. By then they'll have the understanding to be able to contribute.
On a fundamental problem solving level, open source spoils the part of the fun. I only need the executable file, and part of the fun is figuring out how it works and how can I morph that file to make it do other things, or completely change the functioning of the software.
One example I give is rock climbing. Logically, everyone should just take a helicopter to reach the top, or let the community contribute and build the road. But where is fun in that? We are rock climbers and we will rock climb.