News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by edoo on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:47AM (#21682230)
If you can't afford a house there maybe you should consider moving somewhere more affordable.
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by arcticbull on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:53AM (#21682269)
Right but there's no reason for that if you just allow developers to build up. You can live a few blocks from work, next to some nice allocated park land, and if you want to visit nature, take a train.

That's far more humane than demanding your fellow citizens commute hours from the outskirts every day so your real estate investment performs better. If you want to live somewhere greener perhaps consider the commute for yourself?

Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by ch4s3 on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:53AM (#21682263)
This may not have occurred to you, but a lot of people simply can't afford to move and leave the safety net of friends and family. They may also lack skills that would help them secure employment elsewhere. There people are especially vulnerable.

With respect to quality of life, there are far denser cities with much higher quality of life.

Building more homes for the middle income families and individuals absolutely helps everyone, except landlords.

Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by manigandham on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:10AM (#21682390)
Neither of you are incorrect as it's about preferences, but the real problem is one of balance.

A city needs all kinds of people. Affordability and density needs to be moderated so that there's enough diversity in families and employment to function well. Also some of the most affordable areas in the USA are also the most sparse.

Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by arcticbull on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:14AM (#21682432)
> A city needs all kinds of people to function and affordability and density needs to be moderated so that there's enough diversity in families and employment to function well.

I don't necessarily see how one follows the other. So long as there's diversity in, for instance, bedroom count on units, what difference does it make if the units are stacked horizontally as they are today or vertically? To be clear, I'd love your thoughts, I'm not sure myself.

> Also some of the most affordable areas in the USA are also the most sparse.

Indeed because building up is expensive, so it requires demand. There's no demand in the middle of Idaho even comparable to what SF has.

Further, I'm proposing scrapping constraints on new development, not taking peoples 2 story Sunset units via eminent domain and throwing up SoMa style 50 story skyscrapers.

I think it's not an unreasonable place to start by doubling all height restrictions across all of SF. No more of this prime real estate on 17th and Brannan (the SFMTA bus lot redevelopment) getting wanged by a 4 story cap. That should be 20+ no question.

Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by bluGill on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:45AM (#21682712)
Stacked vs horizontal makes differences for some uses and not others. If we are vertical I care is you start a kitchen fire as I have to evacuate just in case, Horizontal makes that need much less likely. There are a lot of hobbies that include large objects that are easier to have in horizontal development (any collector of large objects, a grand piano).

Though the number of people who do that is small in the scheme of things. Grand pianos are often moved via crane - if you only do it once in a lifetime the cost isn't much but if you move regularly it is expensive.

Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by joking on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:42AM (#21682684)
4 - 5 floor is the sweet spot for balancing cost and price, if you go up from there the cost per sq meter increases. The places where economically is worth to go higher than that, is where the land is very expensive and you have to recover that cost having more units.
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by ch4s3 on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:15PM (#21689334)
From what I have read, it's probably more like 4-8 floors. With 8 still being totally possible with with a podium floor or two and wood framing above that. (DC does this now)
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by watwut on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:40AM (#21682659)
> What difference does it make if the units are stacked horizontally as they are today or vertically?

One difference is how far things end up to be after. If they are spaced vertically, everything ends up far from everything.

Not enough people living in the geographic area means that stores wont be there, playgrounds will be empty, school will be far away. Visiting friends means longer drives, commute to work means longer drive.

Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by Excel_Wizard on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:50AM (#21682250)
Different strokes for different folks. Some people like living in dense cities. No reason not to build for them if they apparently enjoy it.
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by Lazare on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:58AM (#21682293)
If you don't like the density, maybe consider moving somewhere with lower density?
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by edoo on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:26AM (#21682546)
Already did. I never realized how bad I had it.
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by throwawaysea on Monday December 02, 2019 @10:18AM (#21683073)
Often times the density hawks are the newcomers, asking to be accommodated. This is true in the bay are and Seattle, for example. So I don’t think it’s fair to ask the incumbents who make up a community to leave.
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by mamon on Monday December 02, 2019 @12:41PM (#21684679)
You actually can have both: dedicate some parts of the city for single-family homes for upper-middle class,other parts for high rise buildings. That's how many cities in Europe look like: high density central districts, then some suburbs. The choice is then: do you prefer short commute and living in apartment, or a bit longer commute, but your own big house.
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by EliRivers on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:57AM (#21682289)
Having to move away from your family, friends, job and the life you know also decreases quality of life. A lot.
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by marcinzm on Monday December 02, 2019 @09:01AM (#21682307)
If you don't like the increasing density then maybe you should consider moving somewhere less dense.
Re:Oakland shows how to expand housing supply: tell develope... by fimdomeio on Monday December 02, 2019 @08:51AM (#21682255)
Which also has a human cost if you have social connections with the other humans around you.