News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by tptacek on Friday June 13, 2008 @10:17AM (#216776)
No it's not.

Anybody in the world can add an AfD tag to an article and put it up for deletion. Go ahead, try it: you can get DHH or Paul Graham listed right now. But without a clear consensus to delete, the article isn't going anywhere. Moreover, once the article survives an AfD, it is harder to delete in the future.

This article is running 2-1 keep. I've never seen an AfD succeed with half that opposition. All you can do at this point is piss the WP hobbyists off, have the delete discussion devolve into an argument about "voting versus debating", and make the discussion that much harder for the deleting admin to assess.

Sorry, I know it's a slow news day, but this doesn't count.

Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by icey on Friday June 13, 2008 @11:12AM (#216811)
Thanks for the heads up on how this works. Not knowing wikipedia's process at all, I would have thought that why's entry was about to be deleted as well.

Now we know that it's not as big a deal as it seems.

Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by thaumaturgy on Friday June 13, 2008 @01:32PM (#216948)
| Not knowing wikipedia's process at all, I would have thought that why's entry was about to be deleted as well.

From the big note at the top of the page:

"This article is being considered for deletion ... Please share your thoughts on the matter at this article's entry on the Articles for deletion page."

There's nothing there to suggest that it's about to be deleted, and getting more information about the process of article deletion is as easy as following the links posted in the note at the top of the page. Wikipedia tries to be fairly transparent about this sort of thing.

Also, note that this article was considered for deletion about a year and a half ago, and the overall consensus was to keep it. It's probably gonna be sticking around, although it needs some heavy cleaning up.

Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by icey on Friday June 13, 2008 @02:23PM (#217016)
"This article is being considered for deletion" seems like a strong indicator that it might be deleted to me.
Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by omouse on Friday June 13, 2008 @11:33AM (#216825)
Well the urgency at least makes people want to hunt around for reliable sources.
Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by xlnt on Friday June 13, 2008 @01:51PM (#216971)
without a clear consensus to delete, the article isn't going anywhere

This isn't true. A blog I like got deleted from wikipedia a while back (IMAO.US back when it was only Frank J) on the charge of not being notable. There wasn't a consensus to delete. There was a huge argument, then they just deleted him.

Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by tptacek on Friday June 13, 2008 @03:05PM (#217057)
WP has a "special" definition of "consensus". It isn't a vote. The way it's supposed to work is, the closing admin reads every bulleted "keep" or "delete" argument, makes a spot decision about whether the arguments are valid, and then keeps unless there's an overwhelming number of "deletes".

WP has a "special" definition of "valid", which is codified in the 8043734897 pages in the WP: namespace that document the valid and invalid arguments. If you care --- and as your attorney in this matter I'm obligated to advise you not to --- you could start by reading WP:ATA.

This is frustrating because if you're not an AfD lawyer, you're left wondering why the closing admin ignored you but paid attention to the "WP:NN"! "WP:RS!" "WP:V!" codes other people used. But that's how the system worked.

In this case, there are keep votes pointing to reliable sourcing in the article. O'Reilly definitely counts. Nobody is going to delete it; it'd wind up in WP:DRV, wasting everyone's time some more.

Isn't Wikipedia fun?

Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by xlnt on Friday June 13, 2008 @03:15PM (#217065)
lol :)

In addition, they seemed to have decided that any reason given by a recently-created account could be ignored, without caring if it's valid.

Oh and the real reason it was deleted is that it's a right-wing humor blog and some of the wikipedia people were offended by it's content.

Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by tptacek on Friday June 13, 2008 @03:18PM (#217071)
What was the blog?
Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by xlnt on Friday June 13, 2008 @03:28PM (#217079)
imao.us

it still exists, but now it's a group blog and not as good.

if you want to try reading a post, this is a good one:

http://www.imao.us/docs/NukeTheMoon.htm

Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by tptacek on Friday June 13, 2008 @03:38PM (#217092)
I'm super liberal, I just wanted to see the AfD for it:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion...

This got deleted because, if you read the "keep" votes, the only arguments were that (a) it had been nominated for several awards, and (b) that it got lots of traffic. Neither are strong arguments.

It definitely didn't help that the blog was conservative and wikilawyers tend either towards shrieky Green Party turboliberalism or, worse, Paulbotism.

Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by xlnt on Friday June 13, 2008 @03:40PM (#217095)
Edit: Oh hell, they deleted some of the keep arguments. I think they deleted keep arguments by people with recently created accounts, or which were not formatted properly.

I am absolutely certain of this. For example, my keep argument isn't there. I don't remember what it said, but I do remember that I posted one. Also there used to be significant vertical scrolling.

Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by rory096 on Friday June 13, 2008 @07:34PM (#217246)
Not a single comment was removed from that AfD. Not only would that be completely against policy and instantly reverted, but I just checked every edit to it. (Yes, I need a life.) The article was deleted because the subject wasn't considered notable, not because there's some conspiracy against conservative blogs.
Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by xlnt on Friday June 13, 2008 @07:43PM (#217251)
Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by tptacek on Friday June 13, 2008 @06:00PM (#217194)
It would be exceedingly weird for them to delete comments from AfD discussions, but if they did, they'd still be in the edit history.
Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by xlnt on Friday June 13, 2008 @08:04PM (#217265)
Re:Why the lucky stiff Wikipedia entry page to be deleted by tptacek on Friday June 13, 2008 @03:45PM (#217098)
See [[Wikipedia:Other stuff exists]]. They think of everything! =)