You're definitely right that its not rational to declare every no-mobile-app company obsolete. My main point is that a company who resolves to a certain technology (web apps in this case) just because they don't know another technology (iOS, Android) isn't adapting to market changes.
Relatedly he's not declaring every tech company without a native mobile app to be "obsolete" — he's declaring non-native mobile apps to be obsolete.
Paragraph four, in bold: "In order to stay competitive, web companies now must provide for all devices."
An expanded quote from that paragraph: "If I’m walking down a hallway, I’ll be swyping on my Nexus S. When I get to my desk, I’ll switch to my MacBook Pro, and when I jump on a long flight, I’ll be typing on my iPad. I expect demand the absolute best user experience on each of these devices, and vote with my wallet for the company that will provide this."
The goal of OrangeSlyce appears to be connecting designers and customers. It's inherently social. Why wouldn't I want to have ready access to browse projects (as a student) or monitor my listing (as a project stakeholder)? I'm not trying to be a prick here, I'm just encouraging everyone to step outside this situation and get objective for a moment. We didn't go with Basecamp for our project management needs, so I'm not in this to stick up for 37 Signals or even my own opinions on their product.
I'm prepared to cede the fact that the author's intention was to address 37 Signals and similar companies, but I really don't understand why I'm being drilled for taking away what I thought was a pretty clear point.
If your business doesn't need a native app, then don't create one. It's really that simple.
There are a vocal community of users that want Flash on their iPad/iPhone/iPod Touch. There are a vocal community of users who want a Facebook iPad app. Apple and Facebook aren't on the path to obsolescence because they don't bend to the whim of their users.
In order for something to be obsolete, it must be operable, but unused. To be on the path to obsolescence, one would expect a decline in use. That's pretty hard to prove in the case of 37 Signals, because they don't publish user-base numbers. Or maybe they do. Does anyone have a source for this information?
I am just struggling to find the point of the article. If he's simply calling out 37Signals, then more power to him. Here I was trying to find something to take away from the article.
That was my simple summary. My takeaway is that software entrepreneurs should consider such issues. As he is right. Mobile web apps aren't enough. The UI paradigm between iOS and Android alone is enough to demonstrate this. I'm going to write a blog post about this tomorrow. Interesting topic that coincidentally I was discussing last night.
The relevance of a native app is strictly dependent on your users' demands. If I'm going to make an investment in a native app for iOS, Android, Blackberry, etc, there had better be a business case. How many users would sign up for my service based on the fact that I have a native mobile client? What percentage of my users are even using a mobile device to access my service?
It's simply not rational to look out across the tech landscape and declare every company without a native mobile app to be "obsolete".